Creepypasta Lemons

{Ticci Toby X Reader}{ Syrup }

~** THIS WAS MADE PURELY FOR FUN LMAO **~

   -Reader's POV-

       I watched Toby eat his waffles happily from the other side of the table. I kinda wished he liked me as much as he liked his waffles. Wow. Listen to yourself. You're jealous of a couple of waffles. Anyways, I have had a crush on Toby since the first month of being one of Slender's proxies. It was some tough work but I managed.

    Toby chewed down on like his forth plate of waffles as I sighed and began getting up from the table to head back to my Bedroom .

      "Hey (Y/n), w-wait up!" Toby twitched while getting up from the table and heading towards me, holding the syrup still.

"What Toby?" You spoke softly, "Why are you leaving?" You were left confused about why did toby care, "I'm just going to my Bedroom Toby..." He responded quickly, "B-But I don't want you to e-even be a f-foot away from me...!" He smiled as he took my hand. My face became pink quickly afterwards.

  "(Y/n)~ I have l-liked you for a while and I-I want you to be m-mine, will you?" He tilted his head while smiling with that adorable face of his. I felt my face become hotter as I answered his question, "Yes!" I yelled as I hugged him tightly. I didn't even wanna let go.

  "And... (Y/n), there's something I have wanted to do with you for a while too..." I was so happy that I had a big dorky grin on my face, "Yes?"

He seemed to hesitate before continuing, "I have been wanting t-try my fetish with y-you?" My eyes widened as I realized what he said, "What...? What is your fetish?" He grinned as he held up the bottle of syrup, "Syrup" I took another moment to take in exactly what he said, "Seriously?" His grin didn't change, "Yep." He pulled me upstairs as I thought about it.

   He pushed me onto his bed as soon as we got up there. He tugged off my shirt causing me to blush a light red, "Toby!" I turned my head way as I covered myself. He used one of his hands to pry my hands off myself and to hold them above my head.

      He popped off the cap of syrup container before pouring a small amount on my edge of my neck. He grinned at your reaction to the cold syrup, your reaction being a cringe because once again, it was cold and sticky, 'Oh my fuck. It's sticky... how far is thing gonna go...?' I pondered the question in my mind. I knew for a fact that Toby would stop whatever he was doing if I were to ask him to but the question was- did I even want him to? Is that why I haven't asked him to stop? My thoughts were interrupted by a warm mouth sucking on the area that Toby poured the syrup. He nibbled away at my neck before licking at the syrup. My face became flustered as he continued his actions.

Soon after all the syrup was gone, Toby sat back to look over his work. You were drooling with what seemed like multiple hickies covering the majority of that area of your neck.

   He undid my bra quicker than one may think he could. I wasn't focused on that though as my blush managed to get darker. He gave the same treatment to my mounds as he did my neck leaving me panting and begging for more. Anything. Toby got the syrup and poured it on my left mound before sucking on it with obscene noises escaping his mouth was doing so. His right hand that wasn't holding to my hand for comfort played with my right mound. I pushed my chest towards his mouth when he moved to lean back.

   Toby smirked at my reaction as he pulled away. I huffed in frustration.

  Toby pulled off his shirt at an incredible speed before sliding mine and his pants off in two swift movements. My pants were discarded onto the floor next to his.

  I could see the obvious dent in Toby's black boxers as he glared at my (F/c) lace panties. Why lace, one may ask. It's because you're fancy. Sort of. Sure. He pulled them down with his teeth as he smirked once again at my dripping core. He got the syrup as he poured it over my clit ''Ah! Toby, It's too sticky!" Not to mention, cold. He didn't seem to care very much as he lapped at the syrup. The action, in which, caused me to throw my head back in pleasure. I felt the bubble in my stomach that had been growing finally pop as I came. Toby happily licked at my juices that dripped out.

    My embarrassment was finally remembered when a fact slapped me across the face-

I'm a virgin.

Toby's hands trailed down my stomach playfully before he had to pull away. He tugged off his boxers before taking a small amount of syrup and applying it to himself.

   He rubbed the tip of himself against your opening before you blurted out the truth.

"Toby... two things. One, it's sticky. Two, I'mma... you know..." Toby looked at me confused so I continued, "...a virgin." He nodded quickly before chuckling, "I'll g-go easy on you (Y/n)~!"

   He pushed in slowly so I could get used to the feeling of being so full. I moaned softly in pain once he got the full six inches. He chuckled weakly, taking my hands into his before grinning that dorky grin that I loved, "Y-You're...so tight."

I giggled back at him before wheezing softly, "I...wonder why." Toby snorted back at me causing me to laugh even during the circumstances. We stayed like that for a couple minutes, just holding hands and laughing.

Eventually, I rocked my hips against his and moaned in pleasure, "Move.."

   Toby nodded a bit before pulling out only an inch or two and thrusting back in. He cursed softly as I hummed in pleasure. The pace he held was a slow and deep one. It was a slow and romantic pace, in my opinion. I eventually moaned loudly as the bubble popped again. I came on to his hatchet as he came deep in me. He pulled out after a moment of both of us catching our breaths. Cum and a very small amount of blood follow afterwards.

   I sighed as Toby fell to my side and wrapped myself in his arms.

"So (Y/n)-" He started, "Think you can put up with the Syrup ?" Toby spoke in a soft amused voice.

"I can deal with it..." I smiled as I pecked his cheek. He blushed as we cuddled on his bed.

"Hey Toby...?"-"Yeah?"-"Did you use a condom?"-"...No..."- "Oh fuck."