Creepypasta Lemons

{Ticci Toby X Male!Reader}{ Movie Night }

-Reader's POV-

It has been around three months since I started my job as Slenderman's proxy, working with Masky, Hoodie, and Toby. My story was basically the same story that everyone's heard here and there. Parent(s) died and so I left home. Found killing and bumped into Slenderman along the way.

Everyone was pretty open to being my friend, even Jeff 'the dick.'

Masky is a fairly strict guy who whenever he isn't busy, is outside talking to Jane while smoking. Jane doesn't really like his habit of smoking so she's been trying to encourage him to stop. He's a stubborn shit so he ignores her but has gone a bit out of his way to try stopping. Summary: he's a nice guy when you're friends with him.

Hoodie is a quiet guy who can come off as shy if you didn't know him. He's a cocky dude who is actually really sweet. He doesn't actually talk to me that often but will talk to me on missions if we get them together.

Toby on the other hand, he was really cute to say the least. He was pretty sensitive and funny. A lot of people view him as annoying but he really isn't. He just likes to voice his opinion because everyone should have that right.

I was currently sitting on the couch in the living room next to Toby, as we watched (Fav. Movie), "I see why you like this movie so much, (Y/n)!" I couldn't help but realize how nice my name sounds coming from him. I never really liked my name all that much but when it comes from him, I really can't dislike it all that much.

Toby slowly scooted closer to me but I didn't realize right away due to being so focused on the movie. I finally realized he was so close to me when I felt his soft hair brush against my shoulder. I've always loved Toby's fluffy hair. It always looked so puffy and light. Fitted him well- but honestly, just about anything fit him. That was about when the sex scene came on.

~ If your movie doesn't have a sex scene- (most won't) just use your IMAGGIINNATIIOONNN to pretend it does ~

The scene was gay. I, of course, had no problem with it due to me being gay. The thing was that no one exactly knew the fact that I were gay. It was fine to be gay in the house but I didn't wanna put up Jeff teasing me.

That was the reason I adverted my gaze. I didn't need anything popping while I was sitting right next to my crush, now did I? I looked over to Toby after a second. He seemed to be enjoying the movie, even the sex scene. That took me a bit off guard, though. I didn't think he'd ever be interested in anything like that. The sound of Toby shifting around in his seat brought me out of my train of thought. It was evident that he didn't feel too well sitting still, "Toby, you okay?" I sounded concerned. Toby gasped in surprise before answering, "Y-Yeah! I'm fine..."

Toby always has been a terrible liar, "Toby, what's wrong?" He lightly before turning his head away from me. I looked him over, until my eyes landed on what must be causing his discomfort. He had a boner, "So this is the problem?" I tapped it lightly after chuckling quietly enough that I was pretty confident Toby didn't hear it.

"H-Hey! Don't poke it...it's not gonna help it." He continued to look away from me but I didn't really care much, "Why did you even get it? The movie wasn't that good." He huffed at me before turning his head back me, his face a nice shade of pink, "Because! I was enjoying the movie...and it was better than you think it is... a-and I-I was n-next to y-you..." It was now my turn to blush before my facial expression of surprise turn into a smirk. I pushed Toby against the pillow on the couch as I took my index finger and thumb to to rub Toby's boner.

"Ah! (Y/n)! W-What are you- ?" I chuckled at him causing him to throw me an embarrassed glare, "I'm helping. Heh. It was my fault, wasn't it?" Toby paused for a split second before letting out a weak groan and nodding at my question. Toby began some sentence but was cut off by me pushing my eager lips against his. He kissed back as I felt his boner grow. This whole situation was interesting enough that even my own had started taking interest.

I slipped off Toby's mouth guard that had fallen around his neck and tugged off his loose dark brown shirt that he wore quite a bit around the house. I looked him up and down with a look of lust in my eyes. He blushed at my expression as I pushed him down fully onto his back. I lapped at his right nipple before I rolled it between my teeth. Toby tossed his head back before chomping on his bottom lip to stop the loud moan that threatened to escape his mouth. His nipple started to bleed slightly but I licked the blood away. It wasn't like it really matter that much anyways. Toby couldn't feel pain. I sucked on it until it was hard making it hard for Toby to contain his weak moans. I scooted back to slip my (Fav. Color) shirt off over my Head to show off my chest. Toby looked me over before smiling that sweet torn smile at me.

I pulled Toby's skinny jeans off after a few seconds of struggling. He moaned in complete relief the moment I got them off his crotch. I pulled my pants off afterwards to show my black boxers as I slipped off our boxers to show both of our erect dicks. I smirked as I rubbed ours together between my hand. I breathed heavily due to the pleasure while Toby shook in his place while struggling to keep himself quiet.

Eventually, he gave up on his goal, "Nghhh! Ah! (Y/n)- please just f-fuck me!" I grinned playfully before nodding. I blipped his body over with his ass in the air before bending down to lick his entrance. Toby managed to shake even more as I took out my tongue and began stretching him out with my fingers. One finger led to two and two led to three. Eventually, I left him a begging mess for my cock.

I placed Toby on his back before I rubbed my dick against his entrance. I pushed into his heat and tightness as I hissed. He completely surrounded my dick, "Oh my god... so...f-full. " Toby tilted his head to the side to mumble that at me before hugging the pillow to his smaller frame as I pulled out and quickly thrusted back in. Toby soon began a moaning and shaking mess after only a couple thrusts. It wasn't long until it became obvious he couldn't hold back any longer and neither could I.

Toby's body went rigid as his cum coated his chest as I continued to pound into Toby's ass. He only had to wait for a couple seconds before I came. I finished inside before pulling myself out slowly while Toby groaned weakly at the loss and the vulgar noise it made.

Cum began to leak out as I picked up Toby bridal-style and carried him to my bedroom to let him sleep along with me.

...and so Masky wouldn't yell at me for getting Toby and the coach too dirty.