-BEN'S POV-
I silently hissed in Jeff's direction from across the freakishly long table. Slender was currently too busy passing out our dinner plates to notice.
I hated the fucking dick. He always thought he was right and had NO self control. Even though that sort of fit a couple other killers, he considered his irritable habits, 'better than yours.' Before long, I got tired of trying to explode his head mentally. I got my plate and put it in the sink when slender wasn't looking and then continued to sneak into the living room. I sighed as I hugged the black pillow on the couch, "Sup elf." I groaned, not wanting to look back at him. I heard him huff so instead of waiting until he got tired of waiting and just pulled me off the couch, I sat up. I came face to face with a smirking Jeff with his arms crossed on his chest, "What do you want, Jeffrey?" Jeff stuck his tongue out at me, "Why'd you skip dinner?"
It was a rather simple question but I didn't want him to know the answer, "I'm wasn't hungry and besides, it's none of your damn business, Woods." Jeff growled at me before pinning me to the couch with ease, "It IS my business, Link and you better watch your mouth before it's ruined.~" I growled back at him, "Like yours, smile boy?"
Jeff quickly smashed his lips onto mine before I could react. I would have thought that he would think that I hate this but secretly, I actually loved every second of this. I refused to show any sign of enjoying this though so I put my hands on his chest and tried to push him off but it didn't do much because I didn't actually try much.
Jeff held my hands up and pushed them roughly above my head holding them there but even then, the kiss wasn't parted for even a second. He pulled back to study his work after a moment...
-Jeff's POV-
I saw a adorable Ben. His flushed face was a nice shade of red and his hair was a total mess. His eyes were lidded and his mouth was slightly opened in awe.
"I still don't see how this cute face could be one of a murderer...~" I growled in a low tone. Ben seemed to snap out of his state after that, "Get the fuck off!" I simply gave him a dark chuckle in return as I grinned at his frustrated expression.
"I am no where near done, Ben...~ I'm pretty sure we both know this.'' Ben looked at my face for a moment before his blush got a shade darker, "Fuck off Jeffrey..." He talked in a soft tone. Personally knowing Ben, I knew he wanted this even though he didn't expect this sort of turn. He was simply trying to put up a tough act and I was fine with that.
I picked Ben up bridal style and quickly ran off to my room before Jane could fuck this WHOLE thing up. I knew for a fact she would if she got the chance. I threw him onto my blood stained bed and watched his cute hair bounce for a moment. He quickly pulled pulled his tunic over his head and tore off his leggings, and shrugged off his boots. In the end, he was left in a pair of boxers and his usual hat. I pulled off my hoodie, shirt and , jeans with ease. I was left only in my boxers.
I hovered over him, leaning in over into his ear, "Wanna skip all the foreplay ?" He eagerly nodded as I rubbed him through his boxers. I lifted four of my fingers up to Ben's mouth, "Suck." He took the four digits into his mouth without an argument, moaning softly around them as he did so due to me continuing to rub him through his boxers. After about a few seconds had passed, I took my fingers out of his mouth at a teasing pace and flipped Ben over so he was on his stomach. He tilted his head to toss me a slight shy look just as I slipped a finger into Ben's back entrance. He gave a quiet gasp of pain and distant pleasure the moment I did. I grinned at his face that looked obviously pained. That look disappeared quickly and was replaced with one of awe and pleasure. He pushed him self back against my fingers, making soft noises as he did so. I pushed in a second finger and did a scissoring motion which caused him to become progressively louder. Ben's moans were echoing of the walls and they certainly weren't helping my boner that I was having to deal with right now, "J-Jeff...hurry!" I rolled my gray blue eyes as I lined myself up with ben's entrance just as I got an idea.
"Tell me what you want, Ben...~"
He gave me a frustrated face but I didn't care, "You, Jeff...geez." I pushed in only about an inch and Ben's reaction was immediate. He gave out a low pained moan.
"You need to be more specific, Benny...~" I heard him growl to himself before looking away from me.
He spoke in a cringe worthy high pitched girl tone, "Oh Jeffrey! Please! I want your cock!" I laughed at his amusing attitude, "Fine." I pushed the rest of my length in so Ben let out a pained yell but quickly bit down onto his arm as to muffle his pained noises. Ben was EXTREMELY tight. I gave a loud moan as suddenly, I began to worry for Ben's pain just a bit, "Just tell me when to move..." Ben quickly nodded, "M-Move. I'm fine..." I grinned as I pulled out till only the head was in but slammed in after at a fast speed, "AH!" I chuckled before speaking in a teasing tone, "Ben~ Your voice sounds so cute right now..." Ben didn't seem to care very much about what I thought as I began picking up my speed. I eventually hit a spot inside him that caused Ben to scream in a much higher voice in his usual one. Without even needing to be told, I aimed for that spot again and got basically the same reaction.
"J-Jeff!! I'm gonna..." He trailed off as I simply nodded, "Me too.."
Ben came onto his stomach in a matter of seconds as I came into his ass. I pulled out as Ben moaned softly in discomfort.
I pulled Ben under the covers with ease and fell asleep cuddling him to my chest.

YOU ARE READING
Creepypasta Lemons
FanfictionThis was smut that was written when I was younger that I cleaned up and now and again continue writing much nicer pieces. This includes multiple Creepypastas X Reader/Male!Reader/Creepypasta stories. DO NOT READ IF YOU ARE NOT 18.