Rdr2 preferences and imagines

💕Who Said I Love You First💕

Arthur- You did. Arthur isn't the best when it comes to words of affection or in general. He had trouble enough that you liked him for who he was and always said he was a good man when he thought he wasn't. When he heard you said "I love you," he just stood there shocked and eventually said "love you too." Without hesitation. Just happiness over taking him.

John- You did. John really isn't the best with words but he damn well tries his best through actions.It would probably be when everybody went to bed and it would be just John and you talking and as you leaned on him, he heard you whisper "I love you" before closing your eyes. Is ten times worse than Arthur when it comes to responding out of shock so bear with him!

Sean- He did. Sean is a very and I mean very loud and not afraid to tell how he feels type of person. However, with you he feels like a school boy. He would probably want to just take a ride with you alone to tell how he feels and to finally spill out how he truly feels.

Javier- He did. Javier is a very loving person and he would probably write a song or poem about you and leave it on your nightstand by your cot. He wanted it to be special so he most likely poured his heart out. Needless to say, his question was answered as you leaned against him  giving him  a hot cup of coffee

Dutch-He did! Dutch is a very expressive person and he has no trouble whatsoever to say what's on his genius mind. It probably be sometime after they picked up Sadie and he couldn't help but admit how you took care of her and he just had to let you know as soon as it was time for sleep.

Charles- He did. Charles always knew that he loved you from the moment he saw you. He knew there was something special about you and after a couple of months of dating he said those three words. Of course he would take you someplace special and make sure everything was just right before letting his heart spill out.