Escaping from Him (Mike x Vincent) [Sequel to Forced into Love]

[Ch. 19] Realizations and Complications

Vincent's P.O.V
I jump up out of Scotts arms, backing away.
"W-W-W-Why?" I stutter and back away as fast as I can. He gets up and runs towards me.
"Vinny...Why what? Are you okay?" He grabs my shoulders in attempt to calm me down.
"I...I thought we had something..." I still back away.
"We do have something! Please don't run away from me...You just had a dream." He hugs me tightly.
"I'm sorry...It scared me..." I hold on to his shirt.
"It's okay. What was it about?" He asks me gently.
"You were doing everything Mike does to me...And you told me that you hated me and that I should kill myself and that you never cared.." I look up at him.
"Poor Vinny." He says softly. "None of that is true..And I would never hurt you. Ever. In any way shape or form. I'd never hurt you."
A few moments of silence pass.
"Do I look like a freak?" I ask quietly.
"What? No of course not!" He shakes his head. "What makes you think that?!"
"These collage kids were laughing at me and staring at all my marks and scars and bruises..." I sigh.
"Don't listen to them. Your marks show how brave you are, Vinny." He smiles at me.
"I think I have to go." I get up. "Jeremy can't cover for me all night." Before I had time to explain, I run out. Running down the stairs and running all the way back to Mike's place. By the time I get there and knock on the door, I'm panting. Mike swings the door open.
"You were out getting me something I heard." Mike smirks at me.
"Y-Yeah." I smile. "But it's a surprise so I'll show you in the morning."
"Alright then." He nods, I walk into his apartment and immediately get into my pajamas.
"Oh yeah." Mike chuckles. "You never got your punishment"
"Please make it fast..." I brace myself. He grabs my wrist that's not in a cast and takes a handcuff, strapping it around my wrist. He chains me by my one arm to the side of his bed. Mike didn't look like he was in a very bad mood tonight which was good I guess. He takes a belt from the dresser and hits me with it, over and over until my face starts bleeding.
"P-Please no more..." I cry quietly. He sighs and unchains me.
"I'm sorry. Did I hurt you?" He asks sympathetically.
I nod, still crying. He picks me up and cradles me in his arms.
"I'm sorry..." He whispers. Did he just apologize.
"It's okay." I whisper back and sniffle. I burry my head in his shoulder and close my eyes. I need sleep for once.

Now they both are being nice to me?

Which one do I go or stay with?

And how do I let the other one go...?