Creepypasta Oneshots, Preferences, and Imagines

Dating Toby would Include...

- Yelling at people who pick on him

- thinking his stuttering is cute

- lots of hand holding and cuddles

- Helping him overcome nightmares

- You guys enjoy slow dancing in the middle of the night

- You always end up cleaning his hatchets

- You think the scar on the side of the mouth is cute, even though he thinks it's ugly

- "Y-Y/n, Y-Y-Y-ou're adorable"

- He blushes really easily, (cute as hell)

- Hugs from behind

- Really scared of losing him, vice versa.

- You guys cuddle in the forest

- Lots of neck kissing

- LITERALLY BEATING THE HELL OUT OF ANYONE WHO MAKES FUN OF HIS STUTTER/TICS

- Wearing his goggles

- Sleeping in his turtle necks

- Everyone thinks you guys are adorable, (Which you are).

- Helping him overcome insecurities (Mostly his scars)