Rewrite The Stars

Chapter 5. The Three way

Kara felt a rush when Oliver's lips parted from hers. I thought it would be weird kissing him considering our evil doppelgängers were married. But maybe it's the buzz from all the champagne or it's the fact that he's actually a really good kisser because it didn't feel weird at all.
  Oliver looked at her with a seductive smile on his face. "Kiss him." he whispered and Kara chuckled as she threw Barry a look and noticed him blushing.
   Barry had never even been thinking about kissing Kara Danvers, ever. But she approached him slowly, and the speedster threw a glance at Oliver who was looking at them with wide eyes, waiting for them to kiss. Barry's heart was racing as if he was running. I can't believe I'm doing this. I must be really drunk. He closed his eyes when Kara placed a hand against his cheek and leaned in and brushed her lips against his. Her lips tasted like the champagne. But it doesn't feel weird kissing her. I thought it would, considering how close we are but it feels good.
  Kara slipped her fingers into Barry's hair and he deepened the kiss. It doesn't feel awkward to kiss him. Huh. I must be really really drunk. But I could see why Oliver is so obsessed with these soft lips.
  Suddenly Kara felt Oliver's hands on her body as he was peeling her blouse off and then he slipped his masculine calloused hands down her soft curves. She sighed softly and her lips parted from Barry's and she slowly turned towards Oliver and gave him a seductive smile. Then she just grabbed another bottle of champagne from the coffee table and gave it to Oliver before she intertwined her fingers with his ring free hand. The other one belongs to Barry. She thought and then she reached for Barry's ring free hand and steered them both towards the stairs.
  Oliver was a bit confused when Kara just handed him the bottle and started leading them upstairs and opened a door to a room that read "guest room".
  "This is basically my room anytime I'm here." she explained while they entered the bright orange room with white and golden curtains and matching bed-set. Kara closed the door behind them and grabbed the bottle from Oliver again and put it on the drawer. Then she walked up to the window and closed the blinds before she put on some romantic music.

You're just to good to be true. Can't take my eyes off you. You'd be like heaven to touch. I wanna hold you so much.

The romantic music caused Barry to grab Oliver's hands and place them around his own bare shoulders while he started singing along to the music and slow danced with Oliver.
  "Can't take my eyes off you." Oliver ended the song together with Barry and then they both chuckled softly before the archer pressed his lips against his husband's smiling lips in a very passionate kiss.
  "Aww." Kara said and chuckled softly. Why am I supporting their love? I feel like I betray my friendship with Iris and Felicity right now. And not just because of playing along with this new reality, but because I'm about to have a three way with them. She opened the bottle of champagne and took a sip from it. I need to be more drunk to go through with this.
  Oliver and Barry eventually had to part their hungry mouths from each other so they could breathe. Then the dominant lover turned towards Kara and pulled her in and kissed her tenderly at first, but the kiss soon became more passionate. He drove a hand into her hair and her lips wandered down to Oliver's scruffy neck.
  Barry was watching them making out and oddly enough it didn't make him feel awkward, he only felt a tiny sting of jealousy, since it looked like Oliver was really into it so when Kara started kissing Oliver's neck, Barry pressed his own lips against the other side of his husband's neck from behind.
  Oliver couldn't help but moan softly and lean back against Barry's bare chest. It feels good to be surrounded by him and Kara.
  Kara's soft hands wandered down Oliver's chest and she suddenly slipped her hands across the waistline of his pants which made him sigh. "Wait..." but Kara ignored him and flipped the button open.
  Barry couldn't help but biting his lip when he saw what the girl of steel was doing. He quickly turned Oliver towards him and kissed him passionately again as the archer drove his fingers into Barry's hair while he ran his other hand down Barry's chest until he reached his pants and flipped the button open. Barry gasped just a few inches from Oliver's lips and he grinned as if he just had beaten him in a fight.
  "Guys." Kara said and they turned towards her voice and noticed that she was sitting on the bed. Their eyes fell on her and she tapped at the covers next to her on the edge of the bed for the boys to join her. Oliver and Barry shared a look and chuckled before they walked up to the bed. They sat down on each side of her and then they both leaned in and kissed her neck. Kara sighed with pleasure while their hands were traveling all over her body.
  Oliver slipped his hand up Kara's leg and unzipped her pants it made her gasp and look at him. He leaned in and kissed her and placed a hand under her chin and deepened the kiss further while Kara was struggling out of her pants.
  Barry felt another sting of jealousy when Kara wrapped her arms around Oliver's strong shoulders and straddled his lap while they were still making out. He couldn't control the urge to kiss Oliver's neck scruffy again and his husband sighed and stopped kissing Kara.
  Oliver turned his head to look at Barry and he could read on his face and based on the bulge in his unbuttoned pants that he was wild with want. Is this a fantasy or is this really happening? It feels more like an incredible fantasy.
  Kara sighed and then she chuckled. "So when do you think your first time was in that newly rewritten reality that you guys can't remember?" she asked and Barry blushed when Oliver brushed his fingers against his cheek.
  "I bet it was our unfinished business." Oliver sighed and Barry smiled at the memory.
  "Yeah. I don't know how we didn't sleep together that night. There was so much sexual tension between us. And I totally wanted you" he sighed and then Oliver claimed Barry's hungry mouth again after he'd finished the sentence.
  "Like right now then." Oliver said with a sigh and forced Kara off his lap so he could pin Barry down on the bed and kiss him passionately again.
  The speedster allowed Oliver's hands to trail down his lean runners body while the kissing heated up. He vibrated slightly when Oliver slipped his hand into those open pants. Both their eyes widened and Barry couldn't hide a gasp when Oliver pulled down his pants and threw them on the floor. Quickly followed by his own before he returned to kiss Barry hungrily again.
  "I want you so much." Oliver whispered with so much want in his voice while he started stroking his husband's hard crotch.
  Barry's lips twitched into a smile and he bucked his hips up. "What about Kara?" he asked.
   Oliver just realized that he had almost forgotten that this was a threesome. He chuckled softly and turned to her to kiss her again. He pinned her down on the bed next to Barry and slipped his hands down her body while he was keeping his gaze on his husband.
  Kara's heart was racing while she ran her fingers down Oliver's chest while they were passionately kissing. Then she could feel Barry roll onto his side and she felt his hands travel up her back to undo her bra. "Do you remember the first time we met and you almost did this?" she asked while she chuckled and grabbed Barry's hands and cupped them around her now bare breasts before he leaned in and kissed her.
  Oliver gasped. Oh god this is so hot. While Barry was kissing Kara, he slipped his fingers inside her wet panties and pulled them down with his other hand. Kara gasped and she and Barry had to stop kissing. The alien looked at Oliver who was only looking at Barry, even when he pressed two fingers inside her. Kara gasped again and then she moaned.
  Barry was biting his lip while watching Oliver making Kara come. "Ollie." she moaned and Oliver suddenly stopped finger fucking her and pulled his hand back.
  Barry looked at him in confusion. He's never reacted like that when I call him that.
  Oliver sighed deeply. "It's my familiar nickname, it's weird..." he said.
  Kara's cheeks flushed red. "Sorry, didn't know. But how come he's allowed?" she asked and Barry blushed too.
  Oliver looked at him and leaned in and kissed him. "Because you make it sound so much sexier." he said and Barry grinned when their lips parted.
  "I really want you inside me...like...now...Ollie." Barry whispered with his voice dripping with want.
  "Okay! I'm gonna be downstairs until you guys are done with that. I really don't wanna see that, even when I'm drunk and thinks you're both hot." Kara said with a chuckle and left the bed. Before she headed downstairs she grabbed a nightgown to put on. She could hear them panting, gasping and moaning for each other while she was waiting downstairs.
  {"oh god, Ollie."}
  {"oh wow, you're really fast at everything aren't you?"}
  {"yeah, especially things I've been waiting for, for five years."}
  {"really?"}
  {"yeah. Since the moment we met."}
  Kara decided that it probably was safe to head upstairs when the gasping and moaning had stopped. She found Barry resting his head on Oliver's chest, both wearing big smiles on their face. "You guys done?" she asked while she slipped into bed next to Oliver.
  Barry looked up and met Oliver's blue blissful gaze. "Are we?" he asked flirtatiously.
  Oliver was shaking his head. "No. But with the sex... for now..." he said and brushed his lips against Barry's forehead before he looked at Kara. "But do you want me too, Kara?" he asked.
  She placed a hand on Oliver's face and leaned in and kissed him. "Yes." she sighed and Oliver leaned in and kissed her again and their make out soon turned into more.

After Oliver and Kara had hooked up while Barry was watching, all three of them were breathing heavily next to each other.
  Barry started chuckling and rolled up on his arm and placed a hand on Oliver's chest. "I can't believe we really did this." he sighed.
  Oliver smiled. "Do you regret it?" he asked and looked from Barry to Kara. They were both shaking their heads.
  "No." they said at the same time and started laughing. Oliver brushed some hair away from Kara's forehead before he gave her a gentle kiss. Then he turned to Barry and brushed his lips gently against his too.
  Kara chuckled. "Can you believe this was your wedding night?" she asked and both Oliver and Barry shared a look and blushed. Barry reached for Oliver's hand and played with the ring on his finger.
  "Who would've thought that I would wake up in your arms this morning, only to end up falling asleep the same way?" he said and Oliver blushed when he leaned in and kissed him again.
  "Definitely not me." he sighed and allowed Barry to cuddle up on his arm while he allowed Kara to sleep on his other arm.