Creepypasta Headcannons(AUTHOR'S AU)

Masky, Hoodie, Jeff, Eyeless Jack, & Lui

Jeff, Masky, Hoodie, & Eyeless Jack were all Childhood friends and Lui was just known to them as Jeff's little bro, but they all still treated him as if he was their little brother, which is why when they all saw each other it was an immediate recognition.