1: Homicidal Liu and Sully
2: Ticci Toby
3: Ben Drowned
4: Nina the Killer Reboot(old one too can't really judge that one as well I can but I won't)
5: Jane Everlasting (the killer)
6: Clockwork
7: Sally and Lazari
8: Eyeless Jack
9: Jeff the Killer
10: Hoodie
11: Masky
Though ig Masky and Hoodie aren't creepypastas they're Marble Hornets characters but the fandom makes it so they're seen as Creepypastas maybe cuz Slender was in some of the tapes. Idk. But here ya go My favorite creepypastas from greatest to least.
YOU ARE READING
Creepypasta Headcannons(AUTHOR'S AU)
FanfictionI've seen a lot of these so I thought, why not make my own
