A Game Worth Playing (BENdrowned x Reader)

~This Feeling~

BEN and I had our little 'staring contest' then I broke the awkward silence by furiously blinking because of the cold dusk air gliding over my (E/C) eyeballs, which made them dry.
BEN seemed to be amused by my eyes uncomfortable condition. "You okay there,
(Y/N)?" BEN chuckled. I just giggled in response.

It was sunset and BEN and I had been walking for what felt like a century but I lost track of time and my phone was dead, but I knew it was a long time. I was exhausted and just wanted to sleep. We walked by an old, hollow tree. "BEN, do you mind if we rest hear until morning? Im kinda tired."
I didn't want to seem like a burden or some weak pansy but I had to ask. I felt like I was going to collapse.
"Yeah definitely, i'm kinda tired too. Plus we'll need the rest." BEN said.
"I thought Creepypastas didn't get tired." I stated.
"We may be invincible but some of us are lazy-asses. I have a big reputation for taking too many naps back at the mansion." BEN said scratching the back of his neck.
"Ah," I simply said. "Can you tell me about the others that live there? I already know about Jeff, Slenderp and of course the fantastic BEN Drowned." I playfully said. BEN blushed when I said 'fantastic'. "Well theres Masky, Hoody, and Toby. They're Slender's proxies. Masky and Hoody are OBSESSED with cheesecake. Hoody is shy but Masky is a bit of an overachiever. He likes to play by the rules and please Slender. Toby can be ANNOYING AS HELL. He's always buggin' people about making him waffles or being boring. He twitches and can't feel pain. The 'not being able to feel pain' is pretty badass if I do say so myself." BEN explained.
"Are those the only ones?" I asked him.
"Oh no, theres Laughing Jack, Eyeless Jack, Sally, Splendorman, Offenderman, Trenderman, Smile Dog, Kagekao, Widemouth, Sonic.exe, TailsDoll and a lot of others who don't live in the mansion."
"Offenderman's name sounds a bit sketchy. What's up with him?" I asked.
"Oh, try to avoid him and DON'T PICK UP ANY ROSES YOU SEE LYING AROUND. Been there done that, its not fun."
"YOU'VE BEEN RAPED?" I yelled.
"He tried but thank Zalgo Slendy got there on time."
"Who's Zalgo?" I asked. I felt dumb asking all these questions. "He's the ruler of CPs." BEN explained more and more about the Creepypastas and their lifestyles. I enjoyed listening to him talk and got this feeling when I heard his voice. His voice was deep and attractive. I could just listen to him talk all day. I felt a wave of exhaustion flood my body. I yawned. "I think I'm gonna get some sleep. Night, BEN."
"Goodnight, (Y/N). I love y-UH I MEANT VIDEO GAMES. I SURE DO LOVE VIDEO GAMES." He laughed nervously. Was he just about to say he loved me?