A Game Worth Playing (BENdrowned x Reader)

~First Night At the Mansion~

Please Slender, Let (Y/N) stay!
Slender thought for a few seconds but it felt like hours.
"Alright I suppose." Slender finally said. "YAY" Sweet! Slender was gunna let (Y/N) stay with us! "BUT on one condition Miss (Y/N)."Slender boldly said. (Y/N) looked up at Slender.
"Are you willing to become a Creepypasta?"
"Yeah definitely!" (Y/N) answered. Yes! Not only is she living with me BUT she is gunna be a CP! Aw this is awesome! Slender introduced himself and (Y/N) smiled. I got butterflies in my stomach. Her smile is so beautiful. I cared about her so much. Normally I don't care about humans, but I couldn't help not caring about her.

We entered the mansion to a big commotion. Typical.
"HAY. You give me my waffles back Jeff!" Toby pouted.
"It's 9:30 at night for fucks sake! No one eats waffle this late!" Jeff yelled back.
"WELL I DO AND YOU GIMME MA WAFFLES BACK." Toby's ratchet side came out a bit.
Masky was on the couch rubbing his temples obviously irritated. Hoodie was curled up on the other side of the couch with his head in his lap. Poor hoodie hated loud noises. LJ was in the corner of the living room laughing uncontrollably about who knows what, surrounded by candy wrappers. EJ was in the kitchen. (Y/N) stood there next to me observing her new home. "You hungry?" I asked her. "Yeah just a bit" she said modestly. I took her into the kitchen and Eyeless Jack was sitting at the table eating kidneys. It didn't seem to bother (Y/N). "Hey Jack, this is my friend and CP in training, (Y/N)."
"Sup (Y/N)." Jack said trying to act cool.
"Hi..," (Y/N) said. EJ just stared at her. (Y/N) noticed and started blushing. I interrupted them staring with "ooookay so (Y/N) what do you wanna eat?"
"Uh anything is fine." She replied shyly. Aw her shyness was so cute.
"Argh Slender has gotta go shopping. We're out of almost everything," I said annoyed,
"How bout some nachos?"
"Okay." She replied staring t the floor.
"BEN BEN do ya wanna have a night tea party?" Sally ran in and squealed. "Ooh! Who are you? You're so pretty!" Sally was mesmerized by her beautifulness. I don't blame her. "Thankyou, I'm (Y/N). What's your name?" (Y/N) blushed. "I'm Sally! Oh! Do you wanna come play with me? We can play dolls or have a tea party!" Sally was excited because we finally had another girl in the mansion. (Sorry no Jane,I despise her.)
"Sure!" (Y/N) replied. Sally grabbed (Y/N)'s arm and took her upstairs into her room. Ugh great. Now she's gunna be with Sally all night...