A Game Worth Playing (BENdrowned x Reader)

~You do?~

*-Your POV-*
I walked out of EJ's room and saw BEN walking past his door as soon as I got out. Shit he's gunna wonder why I was in there. "(Y/N)? Why is your hair messed up? And why is your mascara smeared?(AN:sorry if you don't wear mascara) it looks like you were crying." BEN sounded concerned. "I-I um just fell and hurt my arm y'know. It hurt a lot but I'm all good now." I saved myself.
"So you went in EJ's room for?" He asked sounding protective. I panicked. What should I say? If he finds out EJ will kill BEN....
"He saw me fall and helped me in there." I said. BEN obviously didn't buy it.
"Alright." He said and walked away. I sighed of relief even though I knew he knew I was lying.

*-BEN's POV-*
I went back into my room and shut the door. I knew (Y/N) was lying to me. I sat down on my bed, put my head in my hands and sighed. I wonder what they were doing in his room. (Y/N)'s hair was messed up...you don't think they...no (Y/N) wouldn't do that with him. Maybe she would, I mean they are pretty close to eachother. But I think (Y/N) thinks of Jack as a brother. I know Jack thinks of her as more than that though. I mean what guy wouldn't think of her like that? She's so perfect. Beautiful and Fun to be around. She's so adorable. Sometimes whenever I'm around her I just wanna hug her and tell her how much I love her. Other times I feel like I love her so much that I can only show her one way. On the other hand, Jack probably is pretty attractive from a woman's perspective. (Y/N) probably likes Jack now that I think of it. Ugh they probably did do it. I mean why else would her hair be messed up and she was in his room. I started to tear up. "Why...I was the one who found her first. I have the closest relationship with her why should he get to be with her?" I said out loud to myself. I now started to sob, thinking about how they would probably soon have a relationship together and the whole mansion would know. I fell back on my pillow, still crying. But wait a minute, if they did do it, then why was her mascara running all they way down her cheeks? It couldn't have hurt that bad. She wouldn't have been crying if they did. I needed to know what happened.

*-Your POV-*
I went into Sally's room hoping she wasn't there. I opened the door and thank goodness she wasn't in there. Oh yeah that's right, Slender and her are out grocery shopping. I slumped down on my mattress and started to cry. Hard. After about 5 minutes of crying, I felt weak and I fell on my side to the floor. I looked up at the ceiling and didn't bother trying to get up. I had to get up though. The clothes I was in now disgusted me. They were the ones that EJ ripped off of my body. I hated even looking at these clothes. I took them off, starting to cry again. I walked over to my pile of clothes and winced. "Shit!" I whispered. In between my thighs hurt badly. It felt like I had a bruise and someone kept pressing down on it. This was EJ's fault.. Just as I was about to start changing out of my clothes I heard a knock on the door. "Come in," I said. It was BEN. Great. He had a pained look on his face. "(Y/N)...." He said. I just stared at him, already knowing what he was going to ask. "I know you didn't fall, But I need to know.....what were you and Jack doing?" BEN asked sternly. I thought for a moment, I knew what he thought we were doing.
"BEN listen...it wasn't what you're probably thinking. We didn't....y'know...have sex." I hesitated. BEN looked up. "I know. I thought that at first but then I knew you two didn't do that." BEN said.
"How'd you figure?" I asked.
"Well I know one thing for sure. You were crying. I know it hurts the first time but I don't think it would be enough to bring you to a full sobbing fit. So I figured that wasn't the case. Was Jack hurting you?" BEN said giving me a serious, stern look. I looked down and didn't answer. I didn't know what to say. "(Y/N).." BEN said. Tears were forming in my eyes. "(Y/N) DAMMIT ANSWER ME." BEN yelled obviously worried. "WHAT'D HE DO? I'LL KILL HIM." BEN screamed. "No BEN shhh! Shut up!" I tried quieting him down hoping EJ wouldn't hear him. "You're right I'm sorry." BEN apologized.
"No BEN, you don't have to apologize. Well...I don't know if I can tell you."
"Yes (Y/N) you can tell me anything."
"Okay....well it's hard to explain...well not exactly hard to explain but It's difficult to say. I'm just going to be straight forward with this....Jack...he.." I started to cry again, BEN pulled me in his arms and my head buried in his chest. "Please don't cry." BEN said. I pulled away and stopped crying.
"Okay okay I'm f-fine now. Well EJ...he ra-"
"Shh. I know I know. I'm going to kill EJ. He's not going to touch you EVER again." BEN started to cry and he pulled me into a hug once again. The hug felt amazing. My head was buried into his neck and his arms were around my back. "Never....he's never touching you again. EVER." BEN growled. He got up and before he could leave my room I grabbed him by the shirt. "BEN no...you can't.." I said.
"Why?! Are you crazy?"
"No no I wish you could but...He said if I told anyone...he'll kill you." I said.
BEN looked shocked.
"So what am I supposed to do then?" BEN asked. I just shrugged. We sat in silence for a few minutes. "(Y/N)....," BEN started. I looked at him "hmm?" I asked. "All I want to do is protect you. You mean more than the world to me and I want to hurt anyone who hurts you. You don't understand how I feel about you and I'd do anything to make you happy so just tell me what you want and I'll do it." BEN said. I was surprised. I sat in silence just staring into his eyes and wondering why he just said that. I finally decided to speak up.
"BEN...Why'd you say that?"
"Because I love you (Y/N)."

Did BEN just really say that? This must be a dream. He doesn't actually mean that, does he? How could someone as great as him love someone like me?
"You do?" I asked foolishly and confused.
"Yes I do. I'd do anything to make you smile. I'd work until I died just to see you happy because (Y/N) (L/N) I'm in love with you." BEN said. I was almost in tears. He was being serious. The only other times someone has said something like this to me was pulling a prank on me just to see my disappointment but this was the complete opposite and BEN was serious about it. I finally gathered myself together. "BEN...I-I.....I love you too. More than you could imagine." It was true, I really did love BEN. I kept denying it but somewhere deep in my heart I knew that I loved him. He looked a big shocked at my response. "That's a relief I thought your answer would be completely different." BEN said, his body slightly trembling. To be honest I was shaking as well. "Well then I guess that's good that we both feel the same way...." I said. "Yeah.." BEN said smiling. I smiled back. He leaned in and I knew what was about to happen. I leaned in and we kissed each other gently, yet passionately. Not wanting this to get out of hand because I've had enough 'excitement' for one day, I pulled back. We just hugged each other after the kiss. "I love you so much.." BEN said. "I love you too." I said. This was the start of something amazing.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
WOOO so that was kinda a good chapter right? Tell me your guys' favorite chapter so far, I really wanna know! Critiquing is appreciated, I will by no means get offended if you tell me what is wrong with the book because if I there are flaws with it (which there is) I WANT TO FIX THEM. Alright, this is my second chapter in one day because I guess my creative juices were overflowing. And don't worry loves, this is NOT the last chapter for those who are wondering. There are going to be a few more then finale. For the finale I would like you guys to help me with it! Either comment or PM me ideas! I wanna make the finale special because well, this is my first book. Anywho, have a great night/day!!!