A Game Worth Playing (BENdrowned x Reader)

~Why Jack?~

*-Your POV-*
BEN and I have been avoiding each other for the past week. We've only spoken to each other a few times and the other Creepypastas have started to take notice. I was getting something to eat in the kitchen and Sally walked in. She had a worried look on her face.
"Sally are you okay?" I asked concerned.
"Um...yeah." She said uncertain.
"Sally, are you sure?" I asked giving her a stern, unconvinced look. "You can tell me Sally it's okay." I said.
She thought for a few seconds. "Are you and BEN mad at each other? I don't like it when people in the mansion don't get along..." She trailed off.
"We're not exactly mad at each other....we're ju-"
"You're not mad at eachother? Oh good! I was so worried!" Sally cut me off. Good thing she did that, she just saved me from having to explain what happened. I let out a sigh of relief after she left the room.
*-Eyeless Jack's POV-*
Ugh, why? Why does (Y/N) have to be so...so great? I sat in the living room watching (Y/N) talking to Sally. I listened closely. They were talking about BEN I think.
"We're not mad at each other....we're ju-" (Y/N) started saying but Sally cut her off. I wonder what's wrong between (Y/N) and BEN. In a way I hope it's something bad. If it is then BEN would be out of the picture and (Y/N) would be all mine. I decided to go ask her about it. I knocked on the wall and (Y/N) turned around. "Oh hey Jack!" She said smiling. Oh my gosh her smile is so perfect. "Hey.." I responded. We sat there in silence for a few seconds until I gained the courage to ask her. "Sorry but I couldn't help but over-hear you and Sally talking. Is everything alright between you and BEN?" I asked, my fave turning red underneath my mask. She had a sad look on her face. It took her awhile to answer.
"I-it's nothing." She said.
"(Y/N) I know somethings wrong. I can see it in your eyes." I say. All of the sudden Jeff and BEN walk in the kitchen. Damnit. "Seriously it's nothing." She said getting up and leaving. I sat at the kitchen table then got up and followed her. I grabbed her shoulder just as she was about to go into her/Sally's room. "(Y/N) somethings wrong and I am not leaving until I get an answer." I say a bit harshly and (Y/N) has a slightly frightened look on her face. Kinda cute. "J-jack please it's nothing." She said. I was getting very irritated at this point so I dragged her into my room and slammed the door. "(Y/N) you tell me what's wrong." I demanded.
"Jack w-what are you doing?" She asked. She seemed so afraid. I had control and could probably make her do whatever I wanted. I couldn't hold back anymore. I pushed (Y/N) down on the bed and kissed her roughly. She screamed against my lips and tried to push me away but I grabbed both of her hands and pinned them above her head while pushing my body against hers so she couldn't move. I broke the kiss to see her reaction. "JACK WHA-" I covered her mouth.
"Shhh~ we wouldn't want anyone hearing us would we?" I purred in her ear to intimidate her even more. I loved this feeling of control. I went back into kissing her. Then I moved to kissing her neck. She moaned and I bit down on her neck drawing blood, causing her to whimper. "Jack please....stop." She begged. I was absolutely not stopping. No matter what. I moved my hand up her shirt, still kissing her neck. I groped her then moved to her back and unhooked her bra strap. I removed her shirt and bra. This was going to be fun.

~TIME SKIP BECAUSE I'M NOT GOING TO WRITE THAT OTHER HOOPLA~
*-Still EJ-senpai's POV-*
Once I was done 'working' I rolled next to her. We were both panting. I wasn't sorry one bit.
"J-jack...." She started, still panting.
"Yes?"
"Why Jack?"