Nostalgia Mini Book Awards (JUDGING)

🪐Best in Banner and Aesthetics Final Result🪐

•☽────✧˖°˖☆˖°˖✧────☾•

JUDGE: Kmytho

Judge's note- "You all are amazing graphic designers. Each and every aesthetic and banner stood out in different areas. Even if you don't place in the top 3 do not be disheartened because there is scope for improvement!"
____________________________________

1st position- Total Eclipse of the heart by strawberry1d

1)Style- 5/5
2)Creativity- 10/10
3)Hook- 13/15
4)Catchiness- 7/10
5)Mystery meter- 4/5
6)Originality- 5/5
7)Relativity to the book- 10/10

Total- 54/60

Review- I really love the Aesthetics! You chose the correct pictures which were related to the character's career and characteristics. The way they are made is really unique and I loved Kim Sun-Hi's aesthetic the most! The banner was comparatively nicely designed and was not crowded, but it could have been better. Apart from that, you did a good job!
____________________________________

2nd position- Racing towards your heart by ZenCave

1)Style- 5/5
2)Creativity- 9/10
3)Hook- 13/15
4)Catchiness- 10/10
5)Mystery meter- 4/5
6)Originality- 5/5
7)Relativity to the book- 7/10

Total- 53/60

Review- What really caught my eye was the banners! In a way we can say that they brought you victory. The high quality and picture selection made them stand out the most! Compared to them the aesthetics felt quite crowded. Decreasing the size of the aesthetics ie. turning it from rectangle to square could make them look less crowded. Secondly, turning the pictures in the same quality as the banners will make them so much better! Good job!

____________________________________

3rd position- Romantic story by aurora_2604

1)Style- 5/5
2)Creativity- 7/10
3)Hook- 13/15
4)Catchiness- 10/10
5)Mystery meter- 4/5
6)Originality- 5/5
7)Relativity to the book- 8/10

Total- 52/60

Review- I have read and loved this story before! Jungkook's aesthetic completely fits his character (in the book) but Taehyung's aesthetics gave a more royal and badass kind of vibe rather than an innocent one. I won't advise you to change them, because yeah this depends from judge to judge. As for the banner it is quite simple, the glowing flowers look pretty but the text arrangement is too much towards the left side.I think you did that because you didn't want to overlay it with the flowers but I think it looks a bit off. Knowing how good banners you make in your graphic shop this one can be improved! Good job
____________________________________

4th position- Love to Hatred by Lucandaa

1)Style- 4/5
2)Creativity- 9/10
3)Hook- 12/15
4)Catchiness- 6/10
5)Mystery meter- 3/5
6)Originality- 5/5
7)Relativity to the book- 8/10

Total- 47/60

Review- The picture selection for the aesthetics is nice and goes with the selected color. (Jungkook's yellow one is the best) This seems to be like a simple collage. I advise you to check out apps like Picsart and Incollage because they offer you a lot of designs! Aesthetics can definitely be improved. Coming to banners, they are the best! The picture selection, the blending, the effect and the text everything is perfect!
____________________________________