I'm Emily Catherine Fields

2K 52 2
                                    

Alison's POV:

It's been a week since the sleepover and I still have no idea what to do, both Emily's have been all over me and its clear that they're getting jealous of of each other or themselves rather... anyway Emily 1 is coming over in a minute, because I mean logically I would rather have someone who remembers me around me than someone who doesnt, so right now I'm just waiting for her thinking about how to handle this situation I mean what is it that A wants me to do? I mean I get bitch wants me to choose, but what happens when I do? What will happen to the one I don't choose? And what will happen if I choose the wrong one? My thought are interrupted by a knock at the front door I go and answer it, "Hey Em." She smiles at me, "Hi Ali." I let her in and shut the door behind her, "so... what's up?" She asks me, I shrug in response and she just nods, God this is awkward why does it have to be? Oh yeah because there's two of her and one of me...brilliant. "Lets go upstairs." I walk up to my room and when we reach it I shut the door behind her, lock it and push her up against it, "I don't know what's happening or what's going to happen, but I love you so much Emily Catherine Fields and for one day I want to pretend that everything's normal, can we do that?" I say leaning in so close to her that I can feel her breath on my lips, she nods, I notice her look down at my lips and I do the same and we both lean in letting our lips connect, it feels like ages since I've kissed Emily, and God I've missed the feeling, our mouths mould perfectly together, I gently bite her lower lip and she let's out a really sexy moan I go back to kissing her and she licks my lower lip asking permission I grant it and her tongue explores my mouth, I feel myself being picked up and without disconnecting our mouths Emily places me on the bed so she's now hovering over me, I feel her hand reach down to my breast, she pulls away and takes off her top, "you're so hot Em." She smirks and bites her lip she's killing me! She's just about to reach behind and take off her bra when of course my phone starts ringing, she's sighs and I groan in frustration however I reach for my phone and it says Emily 2 is calling, I groan again but I answer, "hello?" I say, "um hi Ali, it's Emily... oh um Emily 2 sorry, um I'm outside your front door, I was wondering if I um if I could um talk to you?" I frown in confusion, "uh yeah sure, just give me a sec ill be down in a minute." "Oh yeah sure ok bye." "See Ya Emily." I hang up and look over at Emily 1, "so now she's here?" I nod slowly hearing the disgust in her voice, "yeah I'm sorry I didn't know she'd just show up." Emily rolls her eyes, "no it's fine, but if you think I'm leaving, well then you're wrong ok?" I nod, "ok but um could you put your shirt back on?" She smirks, "why? It won't be anything the other me hasn't seen before I mean seeing as she's a copy of me and all." I chuckle, "yeah but I don't think I'd be able to control myself." "Ok well then for your sake I will." I laugh and roll my eyes and walk out the room and go downstairs, I go over to the front door and open it and Emily 2 is indeed standing there, "Hey, I'm sorry for just showing up like this, I mean I would've called but you may not have answered and then I wouldve-" I cut her off, "it's fine, come in." She walks in and spots Emily 1, "what is she doing here?" Emily 2 asks, "I might ask you the same question!" Emily 1 quickly responds "I happen to be Alison's potential girlfriend ok?" Emily 2 says, my eyes widen at this, "yeah? Well I happen to ready be her girlfriend!" Emily 1 replies smugly, I however roll my eyes, "guys I am right here!" I walk away into the living room and sit down they follow me and sit next to me so I get up and sit opposite them both, "So Emily 2 what do you want to talk about?" She sighs and looks at the floor, "I'm here to give you an explanation as to why I'm the real Emily." Silence fills the room but my jaw and Emily 1's jaw drops, "Hold up, WHAT?" Emily 1 practically shouts, "what makes you think you're the real Emily, im the real one!" Emily 2 turns to Emily 1 and glares at her, "let me prove it first then you can take the floor and give your explanation ok? Now if you don't mind shutting the fuck up, I'll begin." She pauses and turns back to me, "look Ali I know you may want to believe that Emily 1 over here is the real Emily because she remembers you and i dont, but dont you think that's what A would want? A would want you to choose the easy answer, but surely if you know A's game at all you would know that that bitch would want to take away someone that you really love away from you? I mean think about it, it sounds like an A thing to do right? And I still remember the others and that could be more punishment for you from A because you may feel left out or unwanted, and that's what A would want isn't it? I may not remember you but I'm trying and I'm already developing a crush on you, we could start over, start fresh and create new memories, but I really think you should believe me when I tell you that I am Emily Catherine Fields." Silence fills the room once again, I sit back in my chair, she makes a really good point, they are all things A would do so what if? "Ok my turn." Emily 1 states, I nod at her to continue, "I remember everything and surely A would make it so that you would sit here and listen to everything Emily 2 and think that sounds reasonable so you choose her, but me the real Emily is taken back by A and tortured and then you find out that you chose the wrong Emily and then you'll never see me again, now I love you and ill respect your decision I always have, but I know in my heart and I hope you do to that I am the real Emily, we've been through so much together, please Ali hear me when I say to you, I'm Emily Catherine Fields." I sigh my eyes fill with tears, I don't know what to do or say, who to choose, I don't want to hurt the other a and I don't want to choose incorrectly, "well? Ali? Who do you pick?" Emily 2 asks, "I-I" I burst into tears, this pressure is too much I don't want to choose why should I, who says I have to, and as if on cue my phone goes off with a new text, I open it and read it,
It's either one or both, you have to pick, think carefully about what each of them have said and choose wisely, oh and feel free to let yourself suffer from guilt and pressure
-A
I wipe away my tears and straighten up, "look this is going to be hard for me, I don't want to do this but I have to, but I also know that I can't do it without the other girls present, so I'm going to call them to come over and then we'll see what happens, im sorry I love you." With that I call the girls and ask them to come over.

Happy New year!!

Not long now! Who do you think it is?

-Stacey

love a little moreWhere stories live. Discover now