CreepyPasta Boyfriend Scenarios

Nine: You Make Him "Excited"

Slenderman

You had just got to the mansion and was planning on spending the night so you brought your bag full of clothes and stuff you needed.

You went to his room and he was barley turning into his human form. You called his human form Justin. You came in and jumped in his arms and he caught you; you screamed, "JUSTIN!"

"I think you like Justin than you like me." He said laughing.

You teased, "Kinda."

He put you down and sat on the bed. You pouted and walked in front of him, "Slender." You sang.

He laid back and kept ignoring you and you got on him. "Slennnddyyy!" You cried.

You jumped up and down on him as you cried out, "Sleeenddyy." and he watched you as your breast bounced. He became stiff and you felt it.

You stopped and got off and you said, "Slenderman!". He embarrassingly looked at you and blushed as he covered himself.

Jeff The Killer

You and Jeff were laying down with each other cuddling. You guys were spooning. He was hugging you from behind and you accidentally pushed your butt into his man parts and then felt something poke you.

You quickly moved and looked at him as he tried to hide what you had just done.

You looked at him and laughed, "J-Jeff."

He looked at you, "Shut up you rubbed your fucking ass on my dick." He covered his parts with a pillow, "what do you expect."

You put your hands up in defense, "hey, I was just saying no need to get hostile."

After a couples minutes went by he was frustrated, "Suck it or something!" He yelled.

You started laughing uncontrollably then made a serious face, "No."

He groaned and said, "Then get out so I can fucking jack off."

You laughed again. "No." Hr laid back and put a pillow over his face as he stayed stiffed.

Eyeless Jack

You and Jack were watching a show called The Sopranos and it showed a part where a stripper was sucking Tony's dick.

You wanted to tease Jack so you said, "Us babe."

He looked dead at the screen and kept staring. He placed his hand over his friend and said, "Yeah.."

You looked down and saw that he was hard, "Uh..Jack.." You said.

"Sorry babe.." He said covering it.

You laughed, "Why did you imagine it?"

"You said us so I did." He said as he laughed slightly.

You looked at him and smiled, "Ones daaay." You sang.

He put his arm around your shoulder, "Can it be today?" He asked.

"Mmmm not today I'm sick" you said as you faked cough.

"Liar." He said.

You laughed, "I know haha but I'm not ready Jack."

"I know." He signed.

Hoodie

You were on top of Hoodie as he had his back against the wall on your bed. Your back was facing him because he was giving you a massage.

"Ahhh right there Brian." You said as he rubbed your back.

"Your bra strap is in the way" he said still rubbing, "take it off."

You laughed, "No I already have my shirt off."

He kept rubbing it and you eventually told him to stop and you laid front still in him as your butt was in the air.

He looked at you and started to become hard. You felt it and got off him and went between his legs, "BRIAN!" you screamed.

He repeated over like five times, "I'm sorry baby."

"No no, my love." You calmed him down because he freaked out, "I'm sorry it just scared me."

He looked at you unsure and you rubbed his head, "Yes its okay baby." You kissed him and he hugged you.

"I just..I don't know guy hormones." He complained.

"It's okay Brian." You said in a sweet voice so he'd calm down.

Evenutally he did calm down and you guys just watched some Netflix and talked about the different movies and shows.

Ticci Toby

You and Toby were laying down talking with one another about birds and bees, "So what do you think it's going to be like when we do have sex." You asked.

"I don't know...a lot of twitching.." He said shyly as he took off his shirt.

You laughed slightly, "No I mean like are you rough or gentle."

He stayed quiet for a while, "I don't know maybe both...is it your first time."

"Yeah." You said getting on him.

"Then I'll start off slow and then slowly become more aggressive." He said as he closed his eyes.

"Not to aggressive." You said in a soft voice.

He let out a soft sigh as if he was moaning. He said, "I'll try baby.." He said as he twitched.

You bounced on him, "Tooobbyyy." You have bounced on him many times before but it seemed as if this time it was different because you felt something rub on you.

"Toby...what is that.." You said looking at him.

His eyes widen and he pushed you off and got sat up, "I'm sorry." He twitched, "I got carried away with my thoughts.."

You came up behind him and kissed his shoulder, "its okay babe I understand.."

He said, "Can you at least rub it?" He said.

You stayed quiet for a while to figure out your answer and finally said, "I don't know how."

His face lit up because you gave him a possibility, "I'll quide you, do what you think is right."

"Another time toby." You said softly.

"Okay baby if that's what you want." He said sadly and then kissed you.