CreepyPasta Boyfriend Scenarios

Fifteen: You Singing

All songs by Melanie Martinez ❤️

Slender man
You and slender man were laying down with one another he was in his human form when you started humming and he was asleep so you decided to sing away.

Melanie Martinez Teddy Bear to be exact. I was petting his head, running my fingers through his hair and hearing his little snores.

Teddy bear, you were my teddy bear
You were comforting and quiet
How did love become so violent?
Oh, teddy bear, you were my teddy bear
Everything was so sweet until you tried to kill me.

You got carried away with the song you finally noticed that Slender was looking at you in bliss and smiled, "Keep singing." he said

You blushed and looked at him, "Uh-Uh-Slender I don't think so..." you said stuttering.

"You don't sing very well but I love hearing it." he said.

You looked at him confused and started singing horribly and he just laughed at you over exaggerated.

Jeff the Killer

You were in the shower and started singing Soap by Melanie Martinez. Jeff had left to go buy you some take out from (Your Favorite Foreign Food)

I'm tired of being careful, tiptoe, trying to keep the water warm
Let me under your skin
Uh-oh, there it goes, I said too much, it overflowed
Why do I always spill?
I feel it coming out my throat
Guess I better wash my mouth out with soap
God, I wish I never spoke
Now I gotta wash my mouth out with soap

You had just finished washing the conditioner and soap off your body and exit the shower when you saw Jeff sitting on the toilet and screamed. "JEFF!" you grabbed the towel and wrapped it around you.

"Keep singing." he said looking at you.

"GET OUT JEFF!" you screamed.

He got up and said, "You act like I have never seen you naked."

"OUT NOW." you demanded. You didn't care that he saw you naked it's the fact he heard your terrible singing.

Eyeless Jack

You were making Jack some stuffed kidneys, you personally don't like them but he wanted them so you wanted to make him happy. You started humming Milk and Cookies by Melanie Martinez.

Ashes, ashes, time to go down
Ooh, honey do you want me now?
Can't take it anymore, need to put you to bed
Sing you a lullaby where you die at the end

You put the kidneys in the refrigerator and didn't notice he was sitting at the counter. When you closed the door you turned around and he was face to face with you and smiled, "Sing more."

You got scared but didn't make a noise but your face was flushed red and you couldn't get any words out. He smiled and started singing, "Ashes Ashes, uh time to go down." You slightly laughed and sang along with him and danced.

You stopped after awhile and he did too, "Where are the kidneys?"

"The fridge I know you saw me put them in there." you said teasing.

"Oh right." he laughed.

Hoodie

You were home alone cleaning because Hoodie had went to Slender's to see what projects he can get. You put the earphones in your ears and started to sing along to, Crybaby by Melanie Martinez while it played on your phone.

They call you cry baby
Cry baby
But you don't fucking care
Cry baby, cry baby
So you laugh through your tears
Cry baby, cry baby
'Cause you don't fucking care
Tears fall to the ground
We'll just let them drown
We'll just let them drown
Cry baby, cry baby

You immediately started dancing to the sound and singing along, cleaning very little. You started cleaning the living room and kept dancing.

Hoodie walked into the front door and saw you dancing and slightly laughed. He went into the room and danced along not knowing the song. You backed up and bumped into him and screamed, "Oh my god!"

He looked at you scared and said, "I'm sorry." you pulled the earphones out of your ears. "You looked like you were having fun and I didn't want to bother you."

You started to laugh, "No haha it's okay." You said unplugging the phone and putting the sound system on and connecting your phone. You played the song again and grabbed Hoodies hands and started to dance with him.

He laughed and went along shaking his booty with you and just having a good time.

Ticci Toby

You and Toby were driving to the Proxy Mansion. When you arrived Toby got out and said, "I'll be right back."

You rolled your eyes an laughed, "Usually that means I'll take thirty minutes."

"I promise." he said laughing.

He closed the door and you waited about ten minutes before you turned up the volume on the radio and plugged in the aux cord and started playing Cake, by Melanie Martinez

I'm not a piece of cake
For you to just discard
While you walk away
With the frosting of my heart
So I'm taking back
What's mine, you'll miss
The slice of heaven that
I gave to you last night

Finally Toby came back and apologized but you didn't care. You drove off and you started to sing again when you stopped at a red light.

You smell just like vanilla
You taste like buttercream
You're filling up my senses
With empty calories
I feel like I'm just missing
Something whenever you leave
We've got all the ingredients
Except you needing me
So respectfully

He looked at you and smiled and tried to sing along with you. You weren't good but you didn't care. You were messing with him and just singing to him as if you were in a music video.

A/N

Sorry for taking so long to update. I'll try to update more.