IT Cast Preferences & Imagines

66• Finn x Reader x Jack pt 2

a/n I suggest reading the first part to the chapter, as it will be difficult to navigate the plot.

After about twenty minutes of trying to find somewhere to get comfy for the all nighter, we finally decided on something.
In the far corner of the store, we sat on the mattresses that were set up for viewing.
Just sitting on our phones, I slowly got up.
"Hey, I'm gonna go to the bathroom."
Finn's mop head popped up from the mattress he and Jaeden were sharing.
"I'll come too."
We all raised an eyebrow.
"Not like that, you dingnuts."

After making a few turns, we got lost in the dark warehouse.
"Uh, Finn. Do you know where we're going?"
His hand that was holding mine dropped. He stopped walking and faced directly in front of me.
"D-do you like Jack?"
Even in the dark I could see the glossiness of his deep eyes.
I didn't know how to answer. I couldn't say yes, but I also couldn't say no.
"Finn... you know what it's like."
That's when I knew he lost it.
"And that's exactly it! Y/n I try so so hard, I think about you all the time and whenever Jack flirts with you- I just. I can't do it. I love you."
He loves me.
But Jack loves me too.
No matter the circumstances, I couldn't stop what I was doing.
I smashed my lips onto his, grabbing the back of his neck, pulling him closer. His warm hands slid faintly under the hem of my shirt. Sharing this moment with him, everything felt right. But whenever I rekindled with Jack, those feelings were there.
Pulling away, swollen lips and heaving chests, I rested my forehead against his.
"Hate to ruin the moment, but we should get finding that washroom."

Coming back, Jack & Jaeden were propping up pillows against the headboard display on each of the beds.
"God, it took you two long enough."
Jack said, rolling his eyes at Finn.
"Yeah, they probably banged in the granola bar section."
Finn threw a pillow at Jaeden.
"Shut up."
I sat back down next to Jack, who immediately got comfortable. His arm slung around my torso, was placed higher on my thigh. When I looked at him, all he could do was smirk.
From my side vision, I could see Finn eyeing his every move. As bad as I felt, I technically didn't say yes to Finn.
When things started to calm down, we started talking. As friends. Not competitors, friends. And it was fun.

A drowsy Jaeden, as well as a loopy Finn, had gotten up to grab waters they'd brought and stashed up front. I was laying in Jack's lap, tracing shapes along his knee, while his fingers played with my hair.
I started to get a bit loopy as well, and that's never good.
"Hey y/n?"
I giggled.
"Yeah, J?"
"You're cute."
"Haha. I know right."
Not even thinking, I sat up and kissed him.
"Oh my god I'm sorry that came out of nowhere."
His eyes met mine, and for a split second; I could see the lust.
His lips met mine, my hand came up to his cheek gently.
I felt myself being leaned back onto the bed by his lower arm around my waist.
When we separated, the warm feeling no longer there, he spoke to fill the silence.
"Please, never leave me."
The sentence came out low and sad.
"I could never."
We heard shuffling, and Jack's lips lifted from my neck. (Wow dude slow up)
He let out a groan, and sat me up.
Jaeden & Finn stood to the side of the display, jaws dropped. Jaeden dropped the water on the ground.
"Jack! What the hell was that!"
Finn's eyes welled up with tears. I'd never seen him like that before. He stormed off, not even giving me a chance to explain.
"Finn."
It was below a whisper, but it was right then and there that I knew.

"Finn! Finn! Finn where are you?!"
I shouted, my voice echoing through the store. I heard a sniffle coming from the aisle over, and that's where I saw him. Sitting in the bathtub display mindlessly scrolling through his phone. He set it down once he saw me. With no words, I sat across from him, my knees up to my chest.
"Hey, Fi-"
"Why did you do that? You go and kiss me and then I see you sucking face with Jack."
His tone was shaky, like a piece of glass about to shatter.
"He's not the one."
I got a puzzled look from him.
"What do you mean?"
"Jack makes me happy, but you make me laugh, cry, question things that I shouldn't question. You've made me love you."
His eyes were wide, a single tear rolling down his cheek. I brought my thumb to his face and wiped it off.
I shifted so I was sitting next to him, cuddled up to his side.
"You know if we stay here, we're probably gonna get caught."
Kissing his cheek, I smiled.
"Well, in that case; it would be my honour to get caught with you."
His laugh rung throughout my ears.
It's Finn.
It was always him.

a/n hA so this was super random but so cute n I loved writing it.