Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

First Kiss

Jeff the Killer:

Your first kiss was on your first date. You were rambling to him about your day while laying in the grass, when he suddenly cut you off by roughly kissing you. You immediately kissed back, getting butterflies in your stomach when he crawled on top of you. Jeff held you down by your shoulders and practically sucked your face off. You ran out of breath and your gentle pushes quickly turned to slaps against his shoulder, desperately trying to get him off you. Finally, he pulled away and you gasped for breath.

"Good lord . . . were you trying to kill me?" You sassed, and his eyes glittered.

"Not exactly." He grumbled, and leaned in again.

Ben Drowned:

Ben would never admit this to anyone, but he had no idea what he was doing when it came to romance. He knew he had to kiss you, and he definitely wanted to, but he was nervous as all hell. He hid this surprisingly well from you, but you knew something was up when he suddenly paused his game and turned to you, grabbing your face. He stared at you for a moment before very quickly pecking you on the lips.

You grinned excitedly, beginning to blush. He leaned in again and kissed you, for longer this time. For the next half an hour, you both just kissed and giggled like idiots.

Eyeless Jack:

It took a while for your first kiss. And when it happened, it was . . . well, kind of scary for several reasons. Of course, you had no idea what he looked like under his mask, but you definitely didn't expect what you saw. You were taking another hike when you two got rather close. You wanted to kiss him so bad, but you didn't want to be rude and just yank off his mask. He seemed to read you mind though, he reached and pulled up his mask just a tiny bit and . . .

His skin was dark gray, his grinning mouth revealed dozens of razor sharp teeth, you could see something blue in his mouth- before you could process anything more you saw in that split second, he quickly kissed you on the lips and pulled his mask back down. Jack grabbed your hand and pulled you along as you continued walking. You barely listened to him as he spoke, you couldn't believe what you had seen.

But you had a feeling you shouldn't ask.

Masky:

Tim wanted to kiss you that night, but knew he shouldn't. So, he waited patiently for the next time he saw you. Patiently as in he kissed you the second you opened your door. Firmly grabbing your hips, he pulled you towards him and pulled up his mask, you barely saw his smirk before he pressed his lips against yours. When he pulled away after a minute, you whined and he snickered.

"Let me inside first, I don't think you want to cause a scene."

Hoodie:

The two of you were sitting on the couch watching a movie when it happened. You were actually wondering when your first kiss would be, when he wrapped his arm around you and pulled you close. Blushing, you gulped when you saw him pull down his mask in the corner of your eye. 'Oh gosh oh gosh oh gosh it's happening.'

"Y/N."

'Oh God oh God oh God.'

You nervously turned to him and he quickly pressed his lips against yours. You froze up and didn't dare move, you were so embarrassed. His stubble scratched against your face, and his lips were so warm. It ended quicker then you wanted, he pulled away and stared down silently at you. Not wanting to face him, you buried your red face in his chest and he rubbed your back.