Legacies Imagines

Make up- Josie

G!P Josie

"Oh fuck, you're so big!" You moan as Josie thrusts into you at a slow pace, savouring the moment as she fucks you for the first time.

You know it's her first time, as it is yours, so you're both getting used to the feeling. You're incredibly sore and sensitive seeming as she just broke through your hymen about two minutes ago, it isn't as pleasurable as everyone says it is, but your sister told you the first few times will be uncomfortable but it gets really good.

Josie whimpers as you clench around her, her eyes widening and she gasps. She wants to grab your hips and fuck you until you pass out, but she read that it's painful for girls when they have their first time, so she refrains from doing that.

"Slow down a bit." You gasp as she speeds up. "You're really big and you're stretching me out loads."

"I'm sorry." Josie whispers and kisses your forehead. "I'm really sorry."

"It's okay, baby, it's a compliment." You giggle and cup her cheeks, moaning when she starts to slowly thrust into you again.

"You're so tight, it feels so good." Josie moans.

"Oh god, you're not gonna suddenly cum are you?" You ask breathlessly.

"N-No." Josie groans, looking down which makes her gasp and look back up. "If I do that again I will!"

"Josie." You moan, arching your back slightly. "You feel so good inside of me!"

"Can I go faster?" Josie asks desperately which makes you nod.

Josie moans loudly as she speeds her thrusts up, more than you like but you let her and try push through the pain. A strangled cry falls from Josie's lips as she starts to pound into your, your skin slapping together which makes you yelp and put your hands on her chest, pushing her back.

"Josie!" You cry out. "S-Slow down!" You beg as tears spring to your eyes at the lingering pain that shocks through your body.

Josie doesn't hear your pleas for her to slow down over her moans, she's too overwhelmed by the pleasure she's feeling. You gaps in pain as she goes even deeper, stretching you out more and more to the point where you're crying. This is not how you wanted your first time to go.

"Stop!" You shout through your tears, pushing her shoulders. Still she doesn't stop, so you reach up and slap her which makes her gasp and stop.

"Baby, what's wrong?" Josie asks worriedly when she sees you crying.

"You were going too fast! I was begging you to stop, jackass!" You exclaim and push her off of you, groaning as she slips out of you.

Josie's face drops with guilt, tears springing into her eyes when she realises she hurt you. "I'm so sorry."

"You know it's my first time, Josie, I told you it was going to hurt me and you knew that. Fuck, Josie, it really hurts." You gasp in pain, tears dripping from your eyes,

Josie's breathing quickens and a tear dribbles down her face as she grabs your clothes and passing them to you. Josie gets dressed as you slip your shirt on, your face scrunching up in discomfort.

"I-I am really sorry, baby, I swear I didn't mean to." Josie's voice trembles, the lump in her throat makes her whimper.

"You know you aren't small, Josie, and you know I was hesitant to have sex because of it. You promised me you would be gentle." You tell her which makes another tear fall from her eye.