Your song
Jeff:
Wonderwall- Oasis
BEN:
Sugar, we're going down-Fall Out Boy
Eyeless Jack:
Can you feel my heart-Bring me the Horizon
Masky:
Nicotine-Panic! At the Disco
Hoodie:
Alone together-Fall Out Boy
Ticci Toby:
Jesus of Suburbia-Green Day
Laughing Jack:
The Sharpest lives- My chemical Romance
Homocidal Lui:
Sweater Weather-The Neighborhood
Lost sliver:
Smells like teen spirit- Nirvana
Bloody Painter:
Fairly Local-Twenty One Pilots
Doctor Smiley:
When I get home you're so dead-mayday parade
YOU ARE READING
CreepyPasta Scenarios
FanfictionCreepy-Pasta boyfriend preferences and Imagines -Requests open- Jeff the Killer BEN drowned Eyeless Jack Laughing Jack Masky Hoodie Homicidal Liu Bloody Painter Dr. Smiley Lost Silver Ticci Toby
