Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When He Hears You Sing

Sooooo I have an obsession with rap (especially Eminem). There might be a few rap songs. Just saying.

JEFF THE KILLER

You were laying in bed with Jeff, he was playing with his knife and you were scrolling through Instagram bored as shit. You saw one of your favorite songs Beautiful by Eminem, and you couldn't help but sing the chorus.
In my shoes just to see what it's like to me be/ I'll be you let's trade shoes just to see what it's be like to/ feel your pain you feel mine go inside each others minds/ just to see what we find look at shit through each others eyes/
That's all you sang before your beloved boyfriend was already sitting up and quietly applauding your amazing voice. You already knew you sang well, but the fact that Jeff The Killer (more like asshole) though you sang good meant the world to you. You blushed and hit his arm playfully, making him smile more (if that's even possible. I mean.. It is JEFF) and laugh a little.
"What? You were AMAZING!" He said hugging you, making you laugh. You rolled your eyes.
"Oh shut it Jeff, I'm not all that great."

SLENDERMAN

You were sitting in the living room with the radio on low next to you, while Slender was in the kitchen reading some big novel. You heard one of your favorite songs come on, which happened to be Talking Body by Tove Lo. You swayed your whole body as you sang the chorus,
Now if we're talking body/you got a perfect one so put it on me/swear it won't take you long/ if you love me right/ we fuck for life/ on and on and on
You stopped when you heard Slender stop turning pages and put his book down, clapping for your great singing voice.
"That was amazing love. Except the cussing." He said with a "smile". You just blushed and looked away, humming and dancing to the music.

BEN DROWNED

You were on Pandora, scrolling through the radios you had (which happened to be every single genre. You love music:)) when you settled on the rap radio. The first song you heard was one of your all time favorites by Notorious B.I.G which was Hypnotize. You laughed to yourself and waited for the chorus to sing along to it,
Biggie biggie biggie can't you see?/ sometimes your words just hypnotize me/and I just love your flashy ways/ guess it's why they're broke and your so paid.
Ben smiled and kissed your cheek, pausing his game of Call Of Duty Black Ops to clap for you.
"That's was great." He said hugging you and kissing the top of your head.
"It wasn't." You laughed and blushed, looking away from you blonde little elf.

LAUGHING JACK

You and LJ were eating candy together and laughing, listening to your Spotify music when Panic! At The Discos song I Write Sins Not Tragedies came on and you clapped excitedly and grabbed a big lollipop, using it as a mic, making LJ stare at you as you sang some of it.
What a shame the poor grooms bride is a whore/I chimed in/haven't you people ever heard of?/closing the goddamn door
You decided to end it there and sat down laughing, putting the candy back. LJ picked up the candy and handed it to you, making you give him a confused face.
"Keep going, no one said to stop." You just laughed and continued dancing around the house, singing and eating candy. Entertaining LJ.

EYELESS JACK

EJ was messing with your music on your phone and pulled up an old favorite of yours, which happened to be the song Knock You Down (a/n I forgot who sings it oops) so you automatically started to sing along to it.
Sometimes love comes around/and it knocks you down just get back up when it knocks you down/knocks you down
EJ gasped and turned to you, pausing the music.
"Never. Stop. Singing."

TICCI TOBY

You and Toby were in your living room just cuddling when the song Guts Over Fear by Eminem ft. Sia came on pandora. You smiled and sang part of the chorus
Guts over fear/ Guts over fear/ For all the times they liked to push me down/ the liked to kick me down/ now I got/ guts over fear/ guts over fear
Today has a wide adorably creepy twitching grin plastered on his face.
"B-babe. I l-love your voice. K-keep going." You giggled and continued to sing to toby the rest of the day.