Jeff the killer- I'll Stand By You by Rachel Platten
Slenderman- Be Your Everything by Boys Like Girls
BEN Drowned- I Won't Let Go by Rascal Flatts
Eyeless Jack- Marry Me by Jason Derulo
Laughing Jack- A Thousand Years by Christina Perri
Ticci Toby- It Will Rain by Bruno Mars
YOU ARE READING
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios
RomanceThe Title Says It All (includes) BEN Drowned Jeff The Killer Eyeless Jack Laughing Jack Slender man Ticci Toby I take requests for others :)
