Sins [Jeff the killer x reader]

Killing again

Reader POV*

While Jeff and you were watching the 'scary' movie neither of you was fazed at all by the blood, gore or jump scares, in fact, you caught yourself smiling while one of the characters was being brutally murdered while Jeff mostly laughed through the movie. After the movie you turned off the TV, as you were about to get up Jeff turned to you, 

"so have you killed anyone since you got out of that cage?" Jeff asked,

that question came out of nowhere. You thought, you looked to Jeff, 

"nope" you answer popping the p,

"but why, didn't you used to kill people?" Jeff questioned,

"I did but.." you trail off

"but what?" Jeff asked 

"i don't want to draw attention, just to have to sins find me" You say a wee bit sad cause you do actually miss killing people, Jeff just looks at you for a moment before it looks like he has some sort of idea,

"one more question" Jeff insisted, you sigh then nod

"if you could, would you kill people again?" Jeff asks.

"Jeff really, do you even need to ask?" you laugh a little, Jeff then lets a creepy grin grow on his face,

"uh Jeff your smile is kinda creeping me out" you added, Jeff then looked at you and your weirded out expression and began laughing,

he's so cute when he laughs. you think to yourself while you continue looking at Jeff while he's laughing,

"I like your laugh" you accidently say out loud, Jeff then stops laughing and looks at you,

"did you say you liked my laugh?" Jeff questioned a faint blush on his cheeks, you then realized you had said that out loud, you quickly look away blush consuming your face then you  try to think of what to say, then you look back to Jeff, he was just looking at you awaiting your answer, 

"no i-i said i like your, uh calf, yeah i said i like your calf, you um must be a good runner" you say trying to play it off cool, which was obviously an epic fail,

"uh yeah, right" Jeff says

"anyways" Jeff begins 

"what?" you ask, your composure now regained

"the reason i was smiling earlier was because i came up with a plan" Jeff responded

"Jeff you came up with a plan wow, bravo bravo" you said sarcastically while clapping your hands,

"shut up and listen" Jeff starts, you then stop clapping and begin listening,

"thank you, now my plan is that you and i go kill but we leave my signature so the cops and everyone else will think it was me" Jeff explains 

"let me guess your signature is 'go to sleep'?" you asked

"yeah, how'd you know?" 

"i read all about you and all the other creepypastas, remember?"

"oh right and I'm only your second favorite" Jeff whispered

"wha-" Jeff cut you off,

"anyways what do you think of the plan?" Jeff asked casually,

"tch, it good considering who came up with it" you clicked your tongue still mad he cut you off,

"hey that hurts" Jeff jokingly said, you smile then 'growl' comes from your stomach, Jeff sighs