Don't Hug Me I'm Scared (X Reader)

Forgiving a Friend (part 2 of I hate that I love you)

A/N: GUESS WHO'S BACK?! ITS ME. I'm really happy that everyone loved the last part of this and I'm still not too inspired but I must continue. Also, requests are off until further notice, I have 35 that I need to do ;u; (that's so many omg) and big thanks to everyone, I honestly love having so many amazing people reading this shit, you guys are nicer than my irl friends (they rarely talk to me anymore, I'm super lonely tbh). I also have a new writing schedule; Sundays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays are DHMIS and FNAFs. Mondays, Wednesdays, and Saturdays are for the Joker and my Sans x Reader. Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Sundays will be for a new upcoming story and my South Park x reader ;) but, here it is guys. I hope you enjoy! c:

You slammed a sticky note with your new number and your address on his locker knowing he was right behind you and made your way out of the school.

This was gonna be an intense Saturday.

You had finally made your way home and went up the stairs, ignoring your brother and mom calling to you asking how your day was. You didn't want to talk at this moment, you wanted to go into your room and scream. As you slammed your door open you threw your backpack on the ground, a loud thud and a pencil snapping could be heard throughout the room. You grabbed your baseball bat that you kept hidden under the bed and climbed out your window. Successfully climbing down the tree you held the bat in your hands tightly. Without any hesitation, you began to beat the tree in full on rage. A scream escaping your lips.

"THIS IS A BUNCH OF FUCKING BULLSHIT. I HATE THAT STUPID BUTTERFLY FREAK SO MUCH RIGHT NOW."

Your neighbor poked her head out of the window. "Hey (Y/n), are you okay?" Lilah asked you.

"Do I look okay Lilah?? My stupid teacher paired me up with stupid asshole Manny today!" You growled throwing the bat and breaking a board on the fence that surrounded your back yard. "Why does the universe hate me?!"

A minute passed and you just quit. Flopping onto the ground face first, it was obvious you didn't care. You were truly upset over this. Lilah rolled her eyes at your overreaction and laughed. "Well, maybe it's the universes way of telling you to try again. Why else would it wait four years to do this?"

You groaned, rolling over onto your back. She had a point, but you refused to admit it. You crossed your arms and pouted. "Yeah, well, fuck you universe. Ya dick."

Lilah's mom called for her to come downstairs, and with a quick 'good luck' she left you to your gross hissy fit. After thirty minutes you decided to get up and get your bat, noticing all the dents that were there. You mimicked Lilah in a high pitched voice and sighed. "God I hate that she's right.."

You sluggishly made your way back into the house and upstairs into your room. You looked at your phone, 2 missed calls and 5 texts from an unknown number. Probably from Manny. Usually, you were never one to call anyone, but this time you had something you needed to say and it couldn't wait. Unlocking your phone you nervously clicked 'call back'.

Here goes nothing I guess..

After a few rings, he finally picked up. "(Y/n)? Where were you, I called you earlier."

"Doesn't matter. Listen, I'm super pissed off about being your partner because you're a dick. I have never been so disgusted by someone, ever. You really hurt me when we were little. I had a huge thing for you and you just threw me away like I was nothing. Like all those years of us being inseparable were nothing. That was bullshit Manny, I thought I could trust you. I opened up to you and only you, but you blew it. I don't think I could ever possibly forgive you for that."

There was silence.

"Okay. I don't expect you to. I don't forgive myself for what I did either, because, in all honesty, I felt the same. Robin and Harry told me that liking girls were for stupid people ad pussies, so I decided that.. I'd listen to them instead of doing what I wanted to do and just tell you. But I didn't I'm a coward when it comes to things like that, I still have those feelings. I never really got over them, especially when I saw you walking around looking fucking flawless. You drove me insane, I wanted to stop seeing you all the time, but even when you weren't around all I thought of was you. I told Mr. Fly to pair us up, I wanted a second chance at redemption from you because I know you still have a big beautiful heart and I can see that you do in those big beautiful (e/c) eyes." Manny sighed. "Those damn eyes. When I try to look away they pull me back in."

More silence. "(Y/n)?"

Nothing. "Please say something..."

There it was. Sobbing. It wasn't because you were sad, it was a wet anger. The worst kind of anger. "How fucking dare you Manny, why would you tell me this? Why didn't you tell me before?! Was leaving really smart? Why would you pick them over me?"

Another sob left you, tears streaming down your face as you clenched a fist. "I've been alone for four. fucking. years. I hate that you did that to me,  was always there for you and when I needed you the most you left. I didn't know what those stupid feelings were or why I had them, but I wanted you there with me and you abandonded me."

"I know. I'm so sorry (Y/n), if I could go back and change it I would. Will you please just consider giving me another chance?"

You sighed, drying your face of the tears that were streaming down your face. "I still have those stupid feelings for you too Manny.. I guess I will, but you better not fuck it up this time. I mean it, I'll kill yoso hard you'll die to death!"

Manny laughed. "I'm coming over to stay the night so we can start this project first thing in the morning. Is that cool with you?"

You hesitated and decided that it would be okay. "Let me ask mom."

With that you ran down the stairs and handed your mom the phone, quickly retreating to a safe distance with a pillow shield just in case.

Your mom looked at you slightly confusd before realizing that it was one of your friends asking you for an answer to a question you had no right to answer. "What did she say (Y/n)? Can I spend the night or no?"

Your mom looked shocked. "Manny? (Y/n) is he wanting toy the night for something that you shouldn't ever do under my roof???"

"Hell no!" You screeced with your face as red as Harry's hair. (A/N: Me and my mom are like this irl, so it's fun to add it into stories.)

Your mom gave you a look that said 'watch it kid. I'll kick your ass.'

You smiled. "I love you mom, please??"

"Please Mrs. (L/n)?" Manny begged with you.

With a sigh, your mother gave in. "Fine Manny, but you watch yourself young man, I don't want no grandbabies."

You threw the pillow, successfully hitting your annoying brother and cheered. Tonight and Saturday are gonna be so much fun!

A/n: Do I smell a three pater?? Yes I do, I hope you guys enjoyed this part because I had fun writing it. I'll try to get part 3 up soon, so be patient with me. And sorry for any grammar mistakes, I'm only one person lol.