Puppeteer x Reader (Why me?)

10.9K 192 15
                                    

You flickered through the snow waiting for the strange silhouette to appear again "Are you there?"you called out out of nowhere

"What are you doing out here in the cold,Y/N?" Toby uttered handing you a h/c scarf as you obtained it contentedly "Thank you" you smiled at him wrapping the fabric around your neck

"So why are you here" he stated sitting next to you as he breathed out "I always find a mysterious figure during this time of day" You grinned from ear to ear

He stared forward towards the horizon as a cold breeze embraced the two of you "So when has this started?"he asked breaking the solid silence "Ever since I visited this cliff" you replied snapping a branch off a tree

"Oh" he said "Do the others know about this" He questioned placing his hands on the cold snow forming a ball

"Nope, only you" you spoke tracing an illustration on the snow "Do you trust me that much to not tell it to anyone except me" He interrogated eyeing you "Well, you seem trustworthy" You said absurdly

"Ha, you trust the prankster in the house" he raised a brow smirking  "Says to the guy who is quite open to everyone" you retort as he snickered

"When will it be appe-" Toby was caught off by a snap of a stick on the path,you eyed it too "Are you there?" You called out hoping the figure would pop up again

"Y/N?" The figure asked "Yes...how do you know my name" You demanded as your eyes glued the woods infront of you

The silhouette slowly made his way to you while taking a quick glance at Toby "Puppeteer?" Toby said examining him "Toby?" The figure replied back

"You guys know each other?" You questioned gazing at them "Yes" they chorused before laughing "You didnt change tob" he beamed at the brunet as he returned it with a slight punch

"Y/N, I know we just met and we pretty much only talked blinded" Puppeteer exclaimed holding out his hand to you "But will you go on a date with me?" He continued

I glanced at Toby as he smirked "Go" he mouthed smiling at your direction before waving off "Sure" you faced puppeteer as he traced a smile on his lips

"You wont regret this" he gleamed smiling

"I hope not" you replied smiling at him as you walked hand in hand towards your home





It sux but thx for reading

Creepypasta X Reader OneshotsWhere stories live. Discover now