Kiyoko's Sister (Nishinoya x Oc)

Paranoia

Ari's POV
I sat in my room crying. I felt helpless. Why would he do that to me. "Ari please open the door!" Noya said leaning against it. "Why should I?" I yell at the door. "So I can explain." He said looking at the door knob. As I open the door and meet his eyes to see him crying too. "Please let me tell you the truth." He said reaching for my hand as I moved away from the door.

We sat on my bed as I looked at the ground. "Ari, the truth is when I first met you the first words I said were 'Her beauty is even more beautiful than Kiyoko.." He said making me look him in the eye. "Tsukishima twisted what I said. What I had really said was that Kiyoko didn't want me and I had excepted that however, I never once said if I can't have Kiyoko I will just have to have her sister." He said crying. "I love you Arimasu and I have since the day I met you." I locked eyes with him as I felt his love like I had the first time he said I love you.

Suga's POV
Tsukishima sat there saying nothing while staring at the ground. Then  Yamaguchi started to talk. "You guys want the truth because I will tell you all right now!" He said boldly. "I don't think you know what your about to do." Tsukishima said without looking up. "Tell us Yamaguchi!" I say looking at the two. "Tsukishima likes her too." Yamaguchi started. "Tsukki thought that is he could get Nishinoya out of the picture then he could have her, but clearly that's not the case at all. He also twisted the story to make Nishinoya look like he said things that he didn't." Yamaguchi froze as he looked at his best friend get up and leave. He felt bad he had hurt his friend, but not about telling the truth.

Nishinoya's POV
We made eye contact as we moved in and we kissed. That kiss felt just like the first one. Every spark rekindled in that kiss. I dried he tears and mine as we went back out to the party in the back. Tsukishima had left and that was that. "So guys I have a different game that we should play and if you get butt hurt then don't play!" I say to the group. "What is it?" Suga looks at me with a wary look. "Paranoia!" I say. "What's that?" Hinata asks Kageyama. Who just happens to shrug. "Paranoia, where you whisper a question to the person next to you and then say a name out loud of someone playing in the group. Someone who isn't playing flips a coin and if it lands on heads then you have to say what the question was if it lands on tails the question stays between you and that person." I explain. "That sounds like fun, I'm in!" Kuroo and Bokuto say at the same time.
*******************************************
⚠️Warning⚠️ this isn't a clean game by any means. If you feel uncomfortable by the game feel free to skip to the next chapter. For those of you that have played or just like fun not so clean games  enjoy!
********************************************
Ari's POV
First Nishinoya whispered a question to me. "That's easy Hinata!" I say with a giggle. "Tails!" Kenma yells. He wasn't playing. So then I asked Kiyoko a question. "Umm Maybe Suga.." Kiyoko says while looking at the ground. "Heads!" "Ahh shit, okay the question was if you could go out with anyone other than Tanaka who would it be?" She said with a small blush. The group laughed as Kiyoko asked the next question. The game went on for a while and it was fun.

"Asahi!" Noya says laughing. "Heads!" Kenma tells to the group!" "Who would you go gay for..". He announced as everyone laughed. Noya whispered the next question to me and I started dying laughing. "Bokuto!" I said trying to stop laughing. "Heads!" Kenma says becoming less interested. "Who would get kicked out of a store for drunken professing their love to the store clerk!" I say still laughing. Everyone laughed and laughed. "Heads!" "Which two people would get caught doing it in a school bathroom" Yamaguchi says the question as Suga and Daichi blush. The game got more and more spicy as time went on.

It was now 4 in the morning and we all agreed it was time to go to bed. I'm glad Noya and I made up. Everyone took air mattresses down stairs as my sister and I made out to our rooms. Plus Tanaka and Noya as our tag alongs. Noya and I went in my room and changed. We crawled into bed exhausted. We said I love you and goodnight. I'm really happy that what Tsukishima said was true. I wonder why he would lie though?
********************************************
Hi guys sorry I've been gone so long. I just finished the musical I was in and now I'm getting so time back. I've got big plans for this story and hope you guys are enjoying. The game Paranoia is a game I learned from my wonderful cast. I hope you guys liked it in the story!

Thank you for reading,
Theresa💛