Friends don't kill friends(Creepypasta fanfiction)

The dare

"Are you okay?" Andy asked.
I frowned. She looked so different from when I first met her.
Now she was thinner and paler and not to mention her blonde hair.
"What's wrong?" She asked, sounding worried.
I smiled slightly "nothing, I'm feeling a lot better. where's BEN?"
There's no way that I wouldn't cry if I ran into him.
She shrugged "Sally's? He hasn't been back for days now."
"Oh" was all I could say.
That's odd for him to not return but then again, why should I care?....
Andy sat on my bed "can I ask you something?" She said like she wasn't sure if to say it.
I shrugged. She already seemed to know everything.
"Is Jana a good person?" She asked.
I was taken back by the question. Why did Jana matter to her?...
I nodded "she's very nice and she covered up for me once so I owe her."
Andy nodded then looked out the window "does Jack love her?"
I frowned "why?"
And then it hit me "you like EJ?!" I exclaimed.
She jumped on me and covered my mouth with her hands.
"Shhhhhh" she told me and blushed.
I giggled when she uncovered my mouth.
She frowned "please don't say anything!" she begged.
I smiled "I won't."
She smiled and hugged me tightly.
Just then Liu walked in and smiled "you're feeling better?"
I nodded and Andy blushed darkly.
"You didn't hear anything did you?" She asked slowly.
Liu looked confused "heard what?"
Andy smiled then turned to me and winked then walked out.
I rolled my eyes. She was so weird.
He watched her leave then turned to me "what was she talking about?"
I giggled and shrugged.
She'd kill me if I told him.
He smiled "want to play truth or dare?"
I shrugged "sure."
He smiled "truth or dare Angel."
"Dare" i challenged.
"I dare you to kiss me." he said with a smile.
I blushed "you-you're kidding right?..."
He shook his head "look, I know you like Jeff but I really like you. like a lot and besides its a dare so you have to do it."
I blushed darker.
He smiled "with as red as you're getting I'm starting to think that you like me too."
I blushed then kissed him.
He held my face and wouldn't let me pull back until we both were gasping for air.

Ugh now I don't know which brother I ship more with Angel XD