You and Jeff were walking on the boat, hand in hand. Pretty much all the creepypastas knew you were back together now, granted some didn't even know you two had broken up...
" You know what Jeff? " You asked, lost in thought. Jeff glanced at you and made a noise for you to continue. " We were so upset about the whole break up, but people have literally made me realise that it was for a day. Like, it feels as though it was for so much longer than that... " You frowned. Jeff squeezed your hand.
" It wasn't very long, that's true. But honestly, when you go through a break up, it seems as thought so much time has passed when not much has. All that matters though, is that we're back together. Hell, we should be happy it was only for a day and not longer. " He answered, looking as though he spoke about this kind of thing everyday. You glanced up at him and smirked.
" You seem like you know a lot about that. " And then your smirk fell. " Wait, you've had girlfriends before me? I thought I was your first! When did that even happen? " You asked, your voice showing confusion and maybe a slight tinge of jealousy. Jeff chuckled.
" Nah, just heard it on some tv show I watched once. You are my first girlfriend. " He smiled at you. You smiled back.
" Man, how I wish you were my first... " You mumbled. Jeff shrugged.
" Eh, what's done is done. All that matters is I'll hopefully be your last. " He sighed happily. You smiled at him and moved so you were squeezed against him, all whilst still walking.
" Damn, a creepypasta can be romantic. How cute. " You smirked. Jeff glared at you.
" Way to ruin the moment (Y/n). " He rolled his eyes. You pouted.
" Sowwy. I hope you're my last too though, so don't worry. " You smiled at him and he smiled back.
~~~~~~~
Jeff had left you to hang out with L.J, E.J and Offender, so you took the opportunity to go spend time with some of the other creepypastas. You made a list of some of them, along with where they would most likely be. The list when as follows:
BEN - Arcade
Masky - Kitchen
Hoodie - Kitchen
Ticci Toby - Probably also kitchen
Sally - Play room
Splendorman - Play room
Slenderman - By the pool, probably on a lounge chair
Trenderman - By the pool
Jane - ???
" You can change that to right next to you. " You yelped and jumped before turning around to see who had just spoken to you. BEN grinned and tilted his head to the left. " Wanted to find me? " He asked. You rolled your eyes.
" You scared the hell out of me. " You frowned at him. " And no, I'm not going to change it, that would mean I'd have to scribble it out and there is no way I'm ruining this piece of paper. But yeah, I did want to find you because I want friends and my boyfriend ditched me for his own. So I figured, might as well one-up him and see more friends than him. " BEN gave you a long, hard look.
" Wow, such a great plan, " he rolled his eyes. " one of your best yet. " You pulled a bitch-face before smiling at him.
" Want to play Mario Kart? " He instantly lit up at your words. " I bet I can beat you again. " You smirked. BEN's smile froze and he scoffed.
" That was once and I've beaten you at least 23 times since then. " He answered. You frowned.
" That was rather precise... Have you been counting? " You asked, a little confused. BEN shrugged.
" What? I wanted to make sure I was the best. Not that I ever doubted it. Just wanted to kick your ass. " BEN replied quickly. You laughed before walking towards the arcade. BEN followed quickly behind you.
" Of course BEN. Of course. " You smiled over your shoulder at him. BEN pouted at you.
" I am the best though (Y/n)... " He muttered. You made a note of how much he looked like an adorable toddler before slowing down and putting your arm around his shoulder.
" Don't worry BEN, " you smiled at him. " I know you are. Let's go prove it. " BEN smiled so happily at you that you couldn't help but smile back. (This may be a weird gang, but I love each and every single one of them. I would not want to live any other way).
A/n - Can a writer find their own story cute? Because I really do... Oh man I hope that doesn't sound vain or narcissistic... Anyways, comment what you liked about this part (if you liked it) and also vote if you liked this part :) I love you all and I will be updating soon! Getting closer to the ending guys! (Not that close but closer than before, haha). I hope you all have a good day/night! See you soon!
~ Abyss
YOU ARE READING
Jeff The Killer X Reader - I'll love you for all eternity
Fanfiction(Y/n) is what people qualify as an average teenager. Going to school, meeting friends and hanging out with her boyfriend. But what makes (Y/n) different is her past. She hasn't told anyone, and everything that happened in the first 13 years of her l...
