Creepypasta x Reader

Chapter 16~BEN Style

~Shit about to get real. And lots of POV switches /-.-/ also gore warning and such.~

LJ POV

Why did Jeff do it?  I don't understand... he could have at least given her candy first... Maybe I should look for her myself... Ugh but this storm I can't. Dammit Jeff..

Jeff POV

"I fucked up Smile... I fucked up real good. I should have waited for BEN to do it so he would be blamed. You know what. I'll be back. Don't tell anyone I'm leaving." I couldn't stand it what I did. It was raining pretty hard and the lightning was bright too but I had to go killing. It always calmed me down so I headed out as usual and ran as far as I could to a nice looking neighborhood. I couldn't wait to go and make everything look... beautiful. Sliced from ear to ear. It's the only way...

Slowly I entered a house and saw one person inside. I checked the entire house and there was only one... I made a mental list of the pros and cons of this.

Pros:

More fun to toy with

Easier to kill

Cons:

Could scream

Eh the young woman looked so peaceful. Ah peace. Something I could only dream of right now. Or ever. Anyways I have a victim right here. Time to get started. I climbed on top of her from the bottom of the bed and took my knife out. I grazed it against her cheek and put my hand across her tiny mouth.

"What a pretty girl... you know what.. smile for me. Otherwise I could make you smile forever. You know what I think I'll do that instead. That way you can be beautiful. Like me."

I was having so much fun toying with her until I heard the door slam downstairs and some loud pounding on the floor like someone fell over. I decided to make this fast and I stuck my knife in the top of her eyelid carving it out and watched the blood pour out. I did the same to the other eye and then made my way to her mouth. I sliced away at the corners until they were cut from ear to ear. Once I was done mutilating her and a good amount of blood was soaking through the sheets and pillow cases I finished her off.

"Go to sleep." I whispered before stabbing her right at the heart and she was done for. I grabbed my lighter and set fire to the wooden bed. I made my way to find a very drunken man collapsed on the floor. I wanted to make this quick so I took my trusted knife and thrust it into his body but of course not before whispering the words I was famous for. Go.to.sleep.

I figured I had enough fun for tonight so I headed back to the mansion and went straight to my room avoiding everyone else. It was still raining so I had to change out of my soaking clothes and into some nice dry ones. It was late so I just laid in bed thinking about where you were and if you were dead yet.

BEN'S POV

~I figured what kinda BEN chapter is this without him in it~

Who did it... it had to be done today... I was thinking that maybe it was better that I'm stuck in here since now I don't have to leave her there. I wondered who carried it out since I couldn't do it. Well LJ and Jeff were there so probably one of them. Who cares about her the least? Jeff. Jeff did it. Dammit Jeff. I just want to get out of this fucking tv and find out what Slender did to y/n...

Slender POV

"Y/n? I told you to leave did I not? Leave now before I have to make you leave." I had to be stern with her otherwise she wouldn't quite understand.

"Why? Why would you make me get to know them and then leave me in the pouring rain and a thunderstorm?!?! What the fuck was the point of that?! This is exactly what I was afraid of. It's all just some bullshit act isn't it. Pretending to care and then kill me just like everyone else! You killed my friends didn't you?!" You started screaming at me and hitting me. It didn't work.

"Y/n stop. You were brought here for a reason, but you are naive and have seen too much. There is no way you would be able to accept your fate. So it is your choice. Die now? Or agree to your terrible fate and live with that truth. Which will it be?"

"YOU CAN'T EVEN FUCKING TELL ME WHAT MY TERRIBLE FATE IS BEFORE I PICK? FUCK YOU"

"You just had to ask. Kill your friends. Live with us. As a creepypasta. That is the choice you must make. You were willing to get to know killers just to save them, but how willing are you to go and save yourself but kill them? The choice is yours y/n"