Chapter 51 - Its complicated

545 6 0
                                    

Natalie gets home in a panic not sure weather to feel sad or angry
"Woah! What happened?" Casey says as he puts him hands on Natalies shoulders
"Kelly was being an asshole! That's what happened!" Natalie shouts
"Come on! Tell me what's going on" Casey says as he sits her down
"We went on the date and it was perfect! Then we went to the beach and saw Gallo and Stella! But the thing was they were kissing and Kelly didn't like that! He still has feelings for her Matt!" Natalie says as she buries her head into her hands
"He's just upset! They ended a couple of months ago! Are you sure your really over Gallo? You were engaged to him Natalie! Surely you miss him a little?" Casey says rubbing her back
"Just a bit" Natalie replies
"See? Now you know where Kelly's coming from! Just give him a little break!" Casey says as he smiles
"Your the best! Do you know that?" Natalie says as she lays her head on his shoulder
"I know! Now let's watch love island!" Casey says as Natalie smiles
Casey turns on love island and Natalie lays her head on his shoulder. An hour later and Natalie has fallen asleep and Casey grabs a blanket and lays it over her. Just then Kelly walks in
"What time do you call this?" Casey whispers
Kelly just slides past him and into the kitchen but Casey follows him
"I'm guessing she told you?" Kelly says as he grabs a water from the fridge
"Yep! Wanna tell your side?" Casey asks sitting down
"I don't get her problem! Of course I made a big deal! I was with Stella for 2 whole years! Of course I still have feelings for her!" Kelly says annoyed
"Yeah but this is when you've gotta chose Kelly! Natalie or Stella? And you might loose them both is your don't chose quickly! Natalie was raging when she came in! Your gonna need to talk to her!" Casey says as Kelly looks at Natalie
"I know! But I can't break her heart! She's already been through that!" Kelly says as he looks away
Little do they know Natalie has been listening and has gotten up
"Break my heart Kelly! See what I care! It's happened so many times now that it doesn't bother me! Maybe I'm not made to become a wife! Maybe it's not in the Lewis blood! Because that's my mom and my grandmother that have both gotten divorced! Maybe I'm next in line to that thrown!" Natalie shouts before shaking her head and walking away

Love at First Sight Where stories live. Discover now