25. Talking with Poppy

1.5K 57 21
                                    

Its been about two weeks. You made sure to text Poppy at least every few days to keep her from coming into the woods again and possibly getting killed.

Slenderman wasnt to happy about you letting her and Daniel go.

And even though he understood he had told you "she was the only exception" but to be careful. Cause if she did see you or the others she would have to die. And you understood.

Right now you were in a tree, outside, listening to music.

You then got a text.

------------------------------------------------------
Poppy🌺

Poppy🌺: Hey Y/N?

You: Sup?

Poppy🌺: How are you? We havent spoken in a while

You: Im fine. Whats up? Is something wrong? Do you need me to go over there and kick some ass?

Poppy🌺: No. No. No kicking ass for you missy

------------------------------------------------------

You chuckle to yourself.

------------------------------------------------------
Poppy🌺

Poppy🌺: This is about you actually

------------------------------------------------------

You freeze. Last talk you heard from her about you was that you were a bit mentally ill and Daniel basically called you insane/crazy..

He was right of course, but it still hurt.

------------------------------------------------------
Poppy🌺

You: Alright..?

Poppy🌺: Are you coming back?

You: No. No poppy Im not

Poppy🌺: But...but why?

You: You wouldnt understand it poppy.

Poppy🌺: but..I thought it was because of your moms death

You: Its...probably better if you stop asking questions now before you find out things you arent suppose to know

Poppy🌺: Are you in like some weird protection program?

------------------------------------------------------

You think for a second.

------------------------------------------------------
Poppy🌺

You: Dont tell anyone, but yeah. Kinda. I basically started...a new life. I have taken a small break from social media for the purpose of the "protection program"

Poppy🌺:...Y/N Im not stupid. You completely abounded EVERY social media thing you have. And we arent even texting on Instagram.

------------------------------------------------------

You started to feel bad. This is for her protection. You cant tell her...you just cant. She will end up just getting hurt..or killed.

------------------------------------------------------
Poppy🌺

Poppy🌺: Please just tell me the truth. This has to have something to do with that weird illness you had before you left.
And the strange men I saw on your Security cameras inside your house, and killed your mother.

------------------------------------------------------

You froze. You completely forgot about those. You put three focusing on youre entire main area Kitchen, living room, and dining room.

------------------------------------------------------
Poppy🌺

You: Strange men..?

Poppy🌺: They were Tim and Brian...werent they? They are the creepypastas Masky and Hoodie.
And you had slendersickness, right?
All those sleep paralysis? Those were just one of them or Toby watching you, wasnt it?
Everything you have experienced, all of it was Creepypastas..
Wasnt it?

------------------------------------------------------

You froze. How..? You felt a shiver. You look up from your phone and turn your music off. You felt familiar eyes on you. But not of Toby, or EJ, no..Poppy-

You gasped and fell out of the tree.

"Ow.." For a second you thought one of the others would come out and help yo up. But as you sit up and look around. You see Poppy.

Her clothes were no longer bright. And, showy. They were mainly black, and baggy..although she kept her crop top hoodie. She wore pants, boots, and a tight shirt under her crop top hoodie. All black.

"O-oh...hey Poppy-"

"What are you doing here?" You stand.

"I could ask you the same thing"

"I was looking for you. Then I saw you up in that tree. What the fuck dude?!"

"Im sorry Poppy I cant tell you about like anything going on in my life right now!"

"Because Im right!"

"No because whatever I say you will just reject my answer"

"You know I can tell when you lie! Im right!"

"Poppy"

"You dont want me to get roped in do you?"

"You cant get roped in. You still have an amazing life. Please-"

"No"

"What?"

"I dont. Yeah sure I wasnt abused. I wasnt even bullied to badly. But you..losing you has been the worst thing ever. I know you cant tell me whats going on. I know you cant show me either. I know I cant truly understand what you have been through. But god damn it man, I have missed you so fuckin much. I hate you lieing to me about things"

"I know..Im sorry. I wish I could bring you with me. But...the boss said I cant. Youre not like me"

"Uh-" she looks down. "How though.?"

"Because the boss..I guess doesnt want you.?"

You then gulp, swallowing your spit. Your vision becomes blurry for a minute and then you look up behind her. Blood drips from your mouth.

"Poppy...behind..you-" you reach out to grab her and pull her from slenderman...but you pass out...

(Sorry it was a bit short!

Hope you enjoyed anyway though!!)

A New Life? (Yandere!Toby x Oc!Reader x Yandere!Eyeless jack)Where stories live. Discover now