~Hoodies P.O.V~
"I-I'll be right back," said (y/n), tears falling freely down their face. They stood up and left the room. The look of pain in their eyes made my chest tighten up. I never want to see that look in their eyes again. Both Masky and I jumped up to follow them.
"Wait," said Slender. We stopped and turned to look at him. "Give them some time to themself. I have a feeling you're going to get hurt if you try to talk to them."
"Why do you think we'll get hurt?" I asked.
"They're very strong, and when someone is upset, they tend to lash out."
"We can handle a (your age or y/a) year old," Masky said with confidence.
"Not this one. They are a whole lot stronger than they look. If they really wanted to, they could probably rip an entire full grown oak tree out of the ground," said Slender.
"Well, that was unexpected. They look so harmless. Now I know why you want them as your proxy," I said.
"(Y/n) locked themself in the bathroom, so if you want, you can wait for them in the hallway. I think they'll be in there for quite a while. Bring them back in here when they come out," said Slender.
"Okay," Masky and I said. We stood up and left the room. We walked down the hall until we made it to the bathroom door. I sat down on the right side of the door and Masky sat down on the left, like guards, blocking anyone from going in and harming them. Now it's time to wait.
~time skip, 45 minutes~
~Masky's P.O.V.~
Uggggghhhhhhhhhhhhhh. We've been waiting out here for forever and it doesn't help that Toby showed up about half an hour ago and started annoying the crap out of me. Every time I yell at him, I hear a small giggle come from inside the bathroom so I guess it's okay that he's here.
"Hey Masky. Masky. Masky. Mask. Mask. Mask. Cheesecake boy. Cheesecake boy. Cheesecake boy. Proxy. Proxy. Proxy. Ti-"
"WHAT!?"
"Hi."
"...Fuck. You."
I heard another giggle come from the bathroom. At least my irritation is paying off. I heard the bathroom doors lock click and (y/n) walked out wiping away the last of their tears.
"Hey, (y/n). You okay?" I asked.
"I'm fine now," they said and smiled up at me. Then they turned to Toby with a sad look. "You were there when my dad died. You saw the bastard that killed him. Who was it?"
Toby gulped. "I don't know her name, but I know she works for Zalgo.
"Ok. We'll have to have a conversation about all that later. Right now, Slender wants (Y/n) back in his office." I grabbed their hand and tugged them in the direction of Slender's office.
They yanked their hand from my grip. "At least get to know me first. Geez," they said before walking to Slender's office on their own.
It's official. I've been bitten by the love bug.

YOU ARE READING
Me? Sarcastic? Never. (Masky x Non-binary reader x Hoodie)
FanfictionThis is the story of a sassy, sarcastic, punny, badass person named (Y/N) and their life with the creepypastas. (Reader is nonbinary/gender neutral) PSA: THIS STORY IS BEING REVISED AS OF 12/27/21. IF YOU READ THIS STORY BEFORE THEN AND ARE STILL IN...