Creepypasta Oneshots

Ticci Toby x Jeff (smut/request)

This was first requested back in June, I am so sorry I didn't get around to it sooner... 😅
————————————-
It had been a while since Toby had pranked someone, and he was bored as hell, so he figured: 'Why not?'

He walked down a hall of the mansion that some of the bedrooms were on. After passing numerous rooms, he stopped in front of Jeff's. Toby smirked to himself, "This is going to be good," he thought. Toby quietly opened the door, just in case Jeff was in there.

After Toby was in the room, he pulled out the pink paint he got from Sally earlier. He found Jeff's knife, which was for some reason under his pillow, and began spreading paint all over it and his bedside table.

He was so focused on painting, he didn't hear Jeff walk in, then close and lock the door...

"Now what do we have here?"

Toby jumped at the sudden voice, he turned around to see Jeff smirking with his arms crossed. "Uhm... u-uh..."

Jeff slowly walked closer to him, Toby backed up and bumped into the bed. At this point Jeff was right in front of him. "Well?" He started, "You going to explain why you were smearing pink shit all over my room?" Toby frantically shook his head 'no'. Jeff raised his eyebrows, and leaned to whisper in Toby's ear.

"Tsk tsk...well, all bad boys must be punished."

Toby's eyes widened. "W-what-t to you *tic* mean?"

"Oh you'll see~"

Before Toby could question him further, Jeff pinned him to the bed. Toby blushed a noticeable red, due to having such a pale face. Jeff smashed his lips on Toby's, kissing him roughly. He licked Toby's bottom lip, begging for entrance. Toby, being inexperienced, keep his mouth shut. Jeff growled lowly, he placed his knee just below Toby's crotch, then rubbed it against the smaller boy's growing erection.

Toby moaned loudly at the strange feeling, Jeff wanted no time slipping his tongue inside Toby's moist cavern. Throughout the make-out session, Toby let small moans slip out here and there. They were music to Jeff ears.

Eventually they had to break apart for air. While Toby was on his back panting, Jeff removed both of their hoodies and shirts, then started on Toby's jeans. After successfully removing both their pants, Jeff teased the bulge in Toby's boxers. Toby gasped and moaned as Jeff rubbed him, feeling himself get harder from the touch. "You like that, ont ya?" Jeff teased. Toby nodded, moaning for more. "Your going to have to work for what you want~~" Jeff cooed, Toby whined at the loss of attention on his throbbing member.

Jeff proceeded to pull down his own boxers and stand up, as well as pulling Toby to his knees. Toby's eyes widened as he stared at Jeff's large member.

"Suck," Jeff said bluntly.

Toby blushed but obliged. He took Jeff's tip into his mouth, licking the slit as salty precum dripped out. Jeffry out a low moan, tangling his fingers in Toby's soft brown hair. He pushed Toby's head closer to his balls. "I know you can take more baby boy~" he cooed. Toby gaged as more length was forced into his mouth, he was deep throating Jeff at this point.

Jeff was on the break of climaxing, but stopped Toby. He pushed the smaller boy on his hands and knees and lined up his dripping cock at Toby's entrance. "Are you ready big boy?"
Toby nodded, feeling a slight pain as Jeff pushed into him. Jeff gave his some time to adjust. After receiving the 'okay', he began to thrust into Toby at a steady pace. A few moments later, Jeff was mercilessly pounding into the moaning boy below him.

After about 10 minutes, both men came at the same time. The two collapsed next to each other. "I-I s-should try t-to *tic* prank you more o-often..." Toby managed to get out in between pants. Jeff nodded in agreement then pulled the covers over them. The two kisses one last time them fell asleep.
————————————————————
Woo! Hope y'all enjoyed that! Huge shout out to Cutieamber567 for the request!
C ya in the next chapter!