Since the two of you had returned home you hadn't left her side, kissing her and holding her whenever you had the chance and she reciprocated the affection every time. Everything about the two of you together just felt right and no matter how early it was or how slow you'd go, the both of you knew you were in it for the long haul.
The two of you cuddle into one another on Madison's bed, home alone. The beautiful blonde looks up to you.
Madison: Hey
You return the gaze.
Y/N: What's up
Madison: Do you... think it'd be ok if we didn't let anyone know about this yet
You look to the girl with furrowed eyebrows, she looks disheartened, like all the negativity you'd helped to get out had returned at once. This was when you remembered the deal.
Y/N: Yeah that's cool, course it is
You look to her with a face of reassurance.
Y/N: It can be our amazing little secret
She looks to you and smiles wider than you'd ever seen before, she leans in and you kiss once more, it only gets even better each time, after a while you pull away.
Y/N: Hey, don't go falling in love with me blondie
Madison: Wouldn't dream of it, cupcake
You then hear the door open and the rest of the coven return, Madison slowly climbs off you and makes her way to Queenie and Nan on the balcony.
Madison: Speak to you later, hot stuff
10 minutes later you hear the girls laughing on the balcony, you approach to see them all looking out into the neighbouring house.
Y/N: Hey what's going on?
They all look around at you smirking.
Queenie: Just looking at the new neighbour. Like butter on a stick
You peer over at him and see him shirtless, moving boxes into the house.
Y/N: Yeah he looks cool
Nan: No Y/N, he's hot
Madison: She's right he's... real hot
She eyes the guy like a predator to its prey. You lift one eyebrow to her in annoyance
Y/N: Oh yeah you're enjoying yourself huh
Madison keeps her eyes trapped onto the ripped new meat, unbothered by what you say.
Madison: Yeah I am
Y/N: Ok well why don't you just go have some fun with him
She snaps her head to look at you quickly, noticing your frustration.
Madison: What the hell's wrong with you dick for brains?! Sad little man worried I'd choose him over you? Hell nobody would blame me
Y/N: Oh yeah real bothered Maddie... if you like him so much go talk to him!
Madison: Yeah I will!
She storms off, you look to Queenie and Nan awkwardly.
Nan: I'm... actually gonna go too
Queenie: Yeah and I got somewhere to be
With that they follow off the same way as Madison. You quickly jog past them to meet the blonde in her room, you see her slipping on a blue dress.
Y/N: You're seriously going?
Madison: Why? You actually jealous now? Well too bad, I want a screw
Y/N: Maddie I can give you better than a screw
Madison: Well I don't wanna find out
Again she pushes past you and makes her way out of the academy. You follow quickly.
Y/N: Ok well I'll come with you
She chuckles.
Madison: If you want to hear him fuck me then sure, come along
Y/N: Why are you being like this? Is it his fucking body? I get it, he's hot, so are a lot of people
Madison: You're hot Y/N, if I wanted hot I'd fuck you
Y/N: Ok so why don't you?
You now come up to his door, seeing Nan already waiting there. She turns and smiles.
Nan: It's cos she wants to make you jealous, she doesn't even like him
You smile at Madison, smug in the knowledge she genuinely liked you and cared enough to make you jealous.
Madison: Get out of my head you little bitch!
She turns to you blushing.
Madison: That's bullshi-
Before she can finish the door swings open. The guy stands there looking to the three of you and you turn to him.
Nan: Welcome to the neighbourhood! We're from next door. I'm Nan
Y/N: What's up man I'm-
Madison pushes ahead of you and sticks her hand out grinning widely, before stating her name.
Luke: I'm Luke, come in
The three of you follow him in, Nan trails behind with you as Madison walks with the new neighbour. Nan turns to you smiling.
Nan: You seriously need to stop worrying, you're all she's thinking about... she just wants to make you jealous
You smile again, ecstatic at this knowledge.
Y/N: Yeah ok, that's good to hear, seriously thanks Nan
Nan: Why do you even care so much?
You chuckle.
Y/N: I don't know, guess I just want to know people like me, even that bitch
Nan: Well she really does, like a crazy amount, And just so you know, everyone thinks you have something anyway, if you wanna keep pretending you don't then go ahead, might be fun
You smile ahead, completely euphoric from the news that your feelings are reciprocated, and you walk into the living room and eye Madison with a light chuckle, knowing that she's oh so fond of you.
YOU ARE READING
Male Reader x Madison- AHS Coven
Romance(Y/N) is Cordelia's adopted son, he's been away for a couple years but recently returned ready to reconnect with his dysfunctional family and help them run Miss Robichaux's Academy. His first act back in town is to attend a party at an old friend's...
