***
Dean; Dean gets you a promise ring, since both of you aren't necessarily in that type of lifestyle to plan a wedding. You get him a goofy hula girl as an accessory to the impala.
Sam; He gives you a collection of books by your favorite author. While you accidentally do the same.
Castiel; He gives you a beautiful bracelet, while you take him to a bee farm. (He wants to buy a bee hive so he can have some for pets, but you say no.)
YOU ARE READING
Supernatural Preferences
Fanfictionpreferences about Sam, Dean, Castiel, and Gabriel (occasionally imagines)
