The New Girl (Jim Halpert X Reader)

Chapter 18

When we got to Jim's house I followed him inside and he set my bag down by the shoe rack

"Tell me" I said. He rolled his eyes and walked to his bedroom

"Tell me" I put my hands on my hips and stared at him

"No" he said as he pulled off his tie and unbuttoned his shirt. I watched him pull off the dress shirt and stared at his shirtless chest. Just looking at him did things to me I didn't understand.

"Tell me" I pleaded him as he undid his buckle

Jesus Christ. I didn't realize how sexy taking off a stupid belt was until now.

He unbuttoned his pants and dropped them to the floor. He was now only wearing black boxers and his black socks.

"Plleeaassee" I gave him puppy dog eyes

"Nnnnooo" he said as he pulled his grey sweatpants up to his hips. I really wanted to know what he was planning but he wasn't gonna just tell me. So I decided to force it out of him. Using the only thing I had available to me. My body

"If you tell me...I'll give you a show" I used my sexiest voice as I slowly unbuttoned my pink top. Jim froze in place and watched me as I undid the first 3 buttons, revealing just the top of my breasts that laid in a black lacy bra

"No" his voice sounded strained as he stared at me. I love horny Jim. He turns into a completely different person. Angry, aggressive, rough, demanding.

"Plleeaassee" I begged again as I bit my lip and undid the last 3 buttons. I slowly pulled my shirt off and watched his erection grow in his sweatpants

"I can't" His voice was low. I dropped my shirt on the floor next to me and slowly gripped my breasts through my bra. Jim bit his lip and watched my hands slowly snake down my stomach to the top of my pants

"Why not" I gave him puppy dog eyes as my fingers danced on the waist of my pants

"It's a secret" His voice huffed a little. He was so turned on right now and it was turning me on even more

"I don't like secrets. And if you don't tell me what you're hiding...you can't have me tonight" I said as I slid one hand into my pants and panties. Jim kicked his lips as he watched me rub myself

"Babe, I-I can't tell you" He said as his eyes locked on my crotch.

I pulled my hand out and turned so my back was facing him. I unbuttoned my pants and slowly bent down as I pushed them off of me. I lingered in the position a little so Jim could get a good view of me. I stood back up and turned to face him. His erection was now extremely noticeably. I pulled off my bra and tossed it behind me. I took the finger that I rubbed myself with and slowly licked it up and down

"Jesus Christ" I heard him say under his breath. I began lightly pinching my nipples with my left hand and snaked my right back into my panties

My fingers moved in circles around my clit and I let out a soft moan. That was the trigger. Jim had been so strong as he watched me but that moan got him. He darted across the room and gripped my by my throat

"I said you can't have me unless you tell me what you're planning" I said as I stared into his firey eyes. He pressed his erection up against me and grabbed my hand from my panties. He placed it on his crotch and I couldn't help myself. I was weak when it came to Jim. I rubbed it up and down and then slid my hand into his pants. I gripped his erection and stroked it slowly

"Fuck" he whispered under his breath as he put his forehead against mine. I knew I had to be strong and get what I wanted. He can't win. I'm strong. I pulled my hand out of his pants and quickly backed away. I shook my head no and smirked

"Not unless you tell me what you're planning" I said. Jim smirked and walked up to me. My back was against his wall and he slid his hand into my panties. His fingers quickly rubbed my clit and I couldn't help but moan. I'm stronger than this. I pulled his hand away and crossed my arms

"Nope. Tell me" I said in a strong voice. Jim shook his head no and crossed his arms back

"I won't" he said

"Then none of this for you" I motioned to my body and walked over to his dresser. I grabbed one of his shirts and put it on

"Fine. I love seeing you in my shirts anyway" he shrugged and gathered up out clothes and threw them in the dirty laundry pile. I squinted my eyes at him as he smiled and walked out to the living room

This guy is something else

I followed and sat on the couch next to him

"What do you wanna watch?" He asked me as he scrolled through Netflix

"Let's watch that movie about that girl who really wanted to know what the big secret was and then the handsome guy finally told her" I said

"Oh, yeah, I already watched that one. Spoiler. She actually finds out because she waited until the next day and actually got to enjoy the surprise instead of ruining it for herself" Jim said

"Different movie. That one sounds lame" I said as I stretched my body out on the couch. My feet laid across Jim's lap and my head laid against a pillow up against the armrest

"How about this one" Jim stopped on a  Tim Burton movie. He knows what I love. I nodded and he pressed play. During the movie Jim would rub my feet and gently run his fingers up and down my legs. I absolutely loved it. I ended up falling asleep before the movie ended and woke up to Jim carrying me to his bed. He set me down and climbed in bed next to me. I kept my eyes closed so he thought I was still sleeping

"Goodnight beautiful...I hope you love tomorrow" He said as he kissed my cheek and pulled me close to his chest. I quickly melted in his arms and fell asleep again