You nervously knocked on Marcy's door. You gave a quick glance over to Finn and Jake, and they gave you a thumbs up. "Marcy's not gonna want to give Hambo up, and I know that. It'll be hard." You said to them.
Marcy opened the door and smiled. "Well if it isn't Y/N." She said. You waved. "Come in!" The vampire requested. You walked in, and Finn and Jake waited outside.
"So, I didn't really get to talk to you much the other day. Sorry about that." Marcy glanced around. "So, I see you've got the crown. You don't plan on using it right, Y/N?" She asked while pointing at Ice King's crown.
"Not for the reason you might think Marcy." She flinched at the nickname. "And that brings me to why I came back..." You began."Finn, Jake, P.B. and I are working together to get Simon back. Bonnie's also going to reduce both our ages so that we don't die immediately. But sadly, one of the spell requirements is an item that existed when we roamed the apocalypse with Simon. You're... going to have to give up Hambo." Marcy gasped.
"But... that was the first thing you gave me. I kept it for all this time." She sighed sadly. You looked at her.
"If you give me that stuffed toy, we can finally see Simon again. Not Ice King... Simon." You reminded her.
"If it's for Simon, then I'll do it." Marcy said, still with a bit of hesitation. She flew into her room and came back with Hambo, the red and blue teddy bear you gave her on the day you met.Marcy hugged the toy tightly, which was all torn up and mangled from age. The red had faded to a pale pink color. "I can't thank you enough Marcy." You said as she handed you the toy.
"You're welcome Y/N." Marcy said while shedding a tear. "See you soon."
———————————————————————————
You and Simon stood at the plane gate. Your heart was heavy with sorrow, knowing that he would be leaving for months. "Simon, do you really have to leave?" You asked. He stopped you.
"Don't worry, I'll be as quick as possible."
"But what am I going to do without you?" You asked. You stopped yourself and sighed. "If it means you're getting that crown your wanted, then I'll do it.""I can't thank you enough Y/N." Simon said, looking back at you.
"You're welcome Simon." You said while shedding a tear. "See you soon."
———————————————————————————
You left Marcy's cave with Finn and Jake following close behind. You glanced at the crown again. There was a small urge inside of you to put it on. To freeze everything, make an ice paradise for you and the Ice King. You fought with the temptation the entire way to the next items."Y/N, you ok?" Finn asked. You nodded.
"Yeah... I'm fine..." You replied.
"Good. We're approaching Wizard City, where we can get the three wizard items." He said, motioning to an empty area. Wizards... were you a wizard? Simon's a wizard now, you thought. You let out a loud scream and reached for the crown. You finally had enough.You felt Ice where the crown should have been. The ring had blocked you. "Stop it Simon!" You yelled. "We can be equal without this stupid spell!" You stopped. Finn and Jake looked at you, shocked. What have you done?
"I'm... so sorry Finn and Jake." You said. "I'm not sure what got into me."
Jake put a hand on your shoulder. "Don't worry
Y/N, we'll get your Simon back. You don't need to pay with your own sanity." You smiled."Now let's go get some wizard's stuff!"
———————————————————————————
Another chapter where stuff goes wrong! Yay!

YOU ARE READING
When I Don't Remember You (Simon X Reader)
Fanfiction"Please forgive me for whatever I do, when I don't remember you." You cross paths with Simon Petrikov, who has an interest in ancient artifacts. One day, he discovers a mysterious crown that would change your lives forever.