5 seconds of summer Preferences

You like him but another band member likes you part 2

Ashton:
You decided to talk to Calum about what happened, and so you excused yourself from Ashton, then went outside to find him. He was sitting down on the ground, looking up at the cloudy sky, watching the clouds pass by slowly. You awkwardly took a seat next to him, hugging my knees but he didn't acknowledge my presence. You cleared your throat, not knowing how to start this off. "Uhm, Calum... I'm sorry about that," You mumbled, scratching back of your head as you put together the right words. "I'm sorry, I know you like me but by now, I'm pretty sure you know the reason why I couldn't like you back," You continued, looking down shyly at the thought of Ashton. You heard him exhale sharply, and he glanced at you with a sad smile. "I noticed it a few days ago, but I just really like you, so I prayed that I was wrong and that you didn't see him that way. But this just confirms everything, now doesn't it, Y/N?" You drew circles on your leg with your finger and nodded timidly, muttering an apology under your breath. "Do you love him?" Calum asked you, as you looked up at him with a shy smile. "I love him so much, it hurts. I don't know what I see in him honestly, but he just makes me feel so happy and I just fell in love with him, you know what I mean? I just love Ashton so much, I don't even know what to do without him," "What?" Your body tensed up when you heard his voice right behind you, and you slowly looked up with fear. He didn't hear that, he didn't hear what you just said. "I-I-Ashton-" you started to stutter, and Calum stood up with a smile. "She's all yours, mate. I'll leave you two alone," he says, walking back to the house, leaving you and Ashton alone outside. You could feel your cheeks heat up in embarrassment, and you didn't know what to do now. He just heard you confessing your love to him, and now you don't know how he'll react. You were scared he was going to leave you just because you like him, and you didn't want that. "Look Ash, c-can we just forget this e-ever happened?" He smirked and shook his head, "I'm never letting this go, babe." He pulled you into a kiss and you could just stand there, eyes widened. Once he pulled away, your soul seemed to come back to your body and you snapped out of your shock. "Wh-why did you-" He giggled, bear-hugging you instead, "I love you so much, why would I want to forget about the day the girl I love says she loves me?" Your heart fluttered at his words and you found yourself giggling along with him. You hugged him back, wishing that this moment would last forever and hoping that this is not just a dream.
Michael:
"But you gotta promise to go out on a date with me," Ashton grins as he stares down at you with those hazel eyes. Yes, you wanted to keep this secret from Michael so bad, and an innocent date with Ashton wouldn't hurt anybody. But the problem is, you don't know how to feel about it. Yes, it's just an innocent date but you feel like you're cheating on Michael somehow. Psh, you aren't even dating, so why are you making such a big deal out of this, Y/N? You bit your lip, contemplating whether or not you should go on a date with him. How would Mikey feel if he found out about it? Would he be okay with it? Would he be mad because you didn't ask him first? Would he be jealous and overprotective? Well, guess there's only one way to find out. "So, would you go out on a date with me tomorrow?" Ashton asked, leaning against the doorframe with a smirk. You opened your mouth to reply when you felt someone's hand on your mouth. You were surprised to see it was Michael, he was standing beside you, his right arm wrapped around your shoulder and his left hand on your mouth. He gave you a sleepy smile then turned to Ashton, "She's busy tomorrow," he says, narrowing his eyes at Ashton. Ashton's eyebrow quirked upwards and his lips pressed into a thin line, "I think she can decide for herself, Cliffo." Michael glances down at you and shrugs, "She has plans for tomorrow, and she's going with me." You look up at him in surprise and he just winks at you, and you knew that he wants you to play along. "Is that true, Y/N?" Ashton turned to you with a pout. "Y-yeah, sorry," You apologized, fixing your gaze on the carpeted floor. "And what will you do?" Ashton asked, and Michael just grinned. "Isn't it normal to take your girlfriend out on a date?" Your eyes widened and your jaw dropped, as did Ashton's. Michael turned to you with a smirk, and kissed your cheek, causing you to blush. "Sorry bout that, Mike. Have fun tomorrow," Ashton grins, winking at me before he skipped away. You turned to him, placing a hand on your hip, "Okay, what was that all about?" One corner of his lips curled upwards, giving you that sexy smirk he keeps doing, which makes your heartbeat race in an instant. "Ashton wanted to set us up," He says, pulling me into his chest. "He told me you had this huge crush on me, and he knows that I really like you, so being the genius he was, he set up this whole plot to get the two of us together," He explain, burying his head into the crook of your neck. You giggled and thanked Ashton in your head over and over, as you nodded, "O-oh, so are you really serious about that d-date tomorrow?" He pulls away for a bit and chuckles, "You don't want to?" You nodded vigorously, taking it back, "N-no! I just-I was just making sure-" "Relax, of course. You're my girlfriend now, right?" Your face heated up when he called you his girlfriend, and he laughed again, mumbling something about how cute you looked before connecting his lips with yours.
Calum:
After that awkward encounter with Luke, you decided that you needed to talk to him, to make sure he doesn't spill the beans to Calum. You asked him to meet you at Macca's, and here you were now, sitting in a booth, facing each other in awkward silence. It was obvious Luke wasn't going to say anything first, so you decided to break the ice instead. "L-Luke, I'm here to talk to you about what you saw the other day," He glanced aat you for half a second before looking back down, finding his fingers a lot more interesting than you. "You haven't told Calum about that, have you?" His eyes flickered to you, and he frowned, "Do you really think I would tell him?" Although Luke wasn't the kind of guy who rats you out, you couldn't be that sure considering he is his best friend. "I-I'm not sure," You say, it was your turn to look down at your fingers and you heard him sigh. "Look, I'm not gonna tell him if you don't want me to. I'm just gonna say this once, and you have to promise to forget about it okay? Don't ever mention it again afterwards," he says, earning him a nod. He took a deep breath before fixing his ocean blue eyes at me and says, "I like you, Y/N. I don't know why, but I like you. But now, I know that I have no chance with you because you like Calum," You blinked thrice, not quite sure if you heard Luke right. He likes you? He has no chance because you like Calum? This feels so unreal, you still can't believe the words coming out from his mouth. You parted your lips slightly, then closed it again, not knowing how to reply to his sudden confession. When he saw your gesture, he continued, "I know you aren't gonna choose me, you're gonna choose Calum," he shrugs. "W-wait a minute, what do you mean by that?" You were clearly confused, and he doesn't even explain anything to you. He gave you a small smile and says, "Calum likes you a lot, he liked you way before I did. So if I were you, I'd go to him right now and ask him out on a date," Luke says, before shooing you away. You thanked him and apologized for not reciprocating his feelings, and promise him he'll find someone better than you, before running all the way to Calum's house to do as Luke suggested. You burst into his room and he gave you a questioning look, but you just marched right up to him and pressed your lips against his. He immediately began to kiss you back, and entangled his fingers in your hair. Your arms were wrapped around his neck within three seconds, pulling him even closer to deepen the kiss. After a minute or so, you pulled away and chuckled, "You should have told me sooner, I love you too, dipshit." He smiled and said, "Luke told you, didn't he? That bastard," You shook your head and pecked his lips, saying, "We should thank him Cal, I never would have done this if he hadn't told me." Calum put his hands on your waist and grinned, "Thank you Lucas, you're the best wingman ever." He leaned in once more, his lips crashed against your own.
Luke:
You were preparing for your movie date with Michael, like you promised, spraying some of your favorite perfume on your neck. You smiled at how gorgeous you looked and sighed, wishing all this effort was actually for Luke, and not Michael. Yeah, Mike's really cute but Luke's the one you like, and you were going with Michael as friends, nothing more. You were gonna head out, when you heard familiar voices arguing downstairs. "What the fuck man?" You heard Michael yell downstairs. "I should be telling you the same thing!" You heard Luke yell back to him. Oh shit. Judging from the sound of their shouts, these aren't their usual playful fights - this shit is getting real. You hurriedly make your way down the steps, and see Luke glaring down at Michael. They looked ready to hit each other at any moment, and you stepped in the middle of them to break them up. "What are you guys fighting about now?" You hissed, looking up at the two of them. Luke fixes his gaze on you, and you could see that his eyes became a darker blue, compared to the usual ocean blue you were used to. "Please don't tell me you're serious about dating him," He says, glancing at Michael who just rolled his eyes at him. "Please," Luke begged, and you could tell he wanted you to deny that so bad. You glanced at Michael nervously, and he was also looking at you expectantly. "Why do you want her to deny that we're dating so bad, huh, Lukey?" Michael smirked, and Luke lowered his gaze to the floor. He didn't reply for a few seconds, but then he lifted his gaze onto you, determination clear in his eyes. "Because I love her, Michael. I love her so much," He says, his eyes looking directly into yours, and you could feel the sincerity in his voice. Your eyes widened, and you noticed Michael's did too, before he smiled and patted Luke's shoulder. "Listen mate, I'm sorry about that. If you told me earlier, I wouldn't have asked her out. You should have called dibs!" Michael hits the back of his head before turning to leave, and Luke approached me with a smile. "I love you, Y/N. Please tell me you love me back," he says, and you raised an eyebrow at him. "And who told you that you can tell me what to do, Lucas?" You were holding back a giggle, because teasing him was fun and he looks so adorable. He stuck out his bottom lip, causing you to nod and let out the giggle you've been trying to hold back. "Of course I love you too, Luke, I honestly wanted you to take me, dumbass." You hit his chest playfully and he gave you a dimpled smile, causing your heart to flutter. "Why don't we just stay here and have a movie marathon?" You thought about it for a bit and agreed, saying, "Yeah, I would like that better. Cuddles are so much better on couches," "And much more comfortable," he adds, plopping down on the couch, pulling you, so you landed on his lap. He wrapped his arms around you, breathing in your scent, and burying his head in your hair. "I love you," he says again, and you say those words back to him, trying to ignore the butterflies going crazy in your stomach.

+++
Please read my other books!!