Everything i wasn't- Cole Walter

21

chapter 21: Bonfire and Betrayal

They spent the next day making plans for the upcoming Saturday bonfire. Cole, eager to bring some joy back into Emerie's life, suggested they invite Jackie and Alex for a night of laughter and warmth. They carefully prepared the details, hoping the event would be a step toward healing.

Excitement buzzed through the air as they finalized plans, knowing that the presence of friends and the school community would make the bonfire an even more memorable and uplifting event. They looked forward to sharing laughter, stories, and warmth with everyone gathered around the flickering flames.

Jackie rushed into Emerie's class, her eyes wide with urgency. "Emerie, you won't believe what I just found out. Cole and Alex both had Paige the same night, and it's causing a huge mess."

Emerie's expression shifted from excitement to concern. "Wait, what? Paige cheated on Alex with Cole?"

Jackie nodded, her voice hushed.

Emerie and Jackie sat in Jackie's room, the weight of betrayal heavy in the air.
"I can't believe they kept this from us, Emerie." Jackie looked down fiddling with her fingers.

"I thought we were supposed to be a team, Jacks. How could they do this to us?"Emerie sighed
"And Paige cheating on Alex with Cole? It's like a nightmare."Jackie continued.

"I trusted them, Jacks. We both did."

"We need to confront them, Em. This can't be swept under the rug."

"You're right. We deserve to know the truth. Let's talk to them and figure out what really happened."

Emerie and Jackie, despite the turmoil of emotions, agreed to keep their discovery under wraps until the upcoming Saturday, the night of the bonfire. They knew the truth had to come out, but they wanted to confront Cole and Alex in a setting where emotions could be laid bare and resolutions sought.

"Let's not ruin the atmosphere at the bonfire. We'll talk to them then.

"Agreed. It's not just about Paige; it's about honesty and trust."

"And we'll make sure they can't evade the conversation."

With a determined pact in place, the girls decided to carry the weight of the revelation until the right moment presented itself at the school bonfire.
————————

As Emerie and Jackie weaved through the lively crowd at the school bonfire, the flickering flames cast shadows on the faces gathered around. The night buzzed with laughter and music, but an uneasy tension lingered beneath the surface.

Approaching Cole and Alex near the crackling bonfire, warmth illuminated their faces. Cole's eyes lit up with a grin, and Alex greeted them with a nod, blissfully unaware of the brewing storm.

Emerie shared a glance with Jackie, their silent understanding palpable in the glow of the bonfire.

Emerie's voice cut through the crackling of the bonfire as she began to unravel the details of the untold story. Her words were measured, each revelation casting shadows on the once vibrant atmosphere.

Emerie speaking with a mix of disbelief and disappointment."Cole, I found out about Paige and what happened during the summer. Alex and you... with Paige."

Cole's expression shifted from confusion to realization, and the lively flicker of the bonfire seemed to waver.

Emerie continued, recounting what she had learned, feeling a growing sense of disappointment in the unraveling of the truth. The warmth of the bonfire provided little solace as she navigated the complex web of emotions.

"Why didn't you even mention it to me? And why would you hook up with your brother's girlfriend,it's so fucked Cole."

Cole took a pause to think about what he just heard his girlfriend say.
"Look,Emerie. It's not like that. I didn't even know she was with Alex back then. And when i found out, it was too late and it tore us apart.I didn't want to burden you with my mistakes. Paige is history, and I'm with you now. I messed up, and I regret it, but it's not who I am anymore."

Emerie's disappointment clung to her expression as she absorbed Cole's explanation. The bonfire's crackle seemed to underscore the tension between them, and the distant laughter of their peers felt like a distant echo.

Cole's eyes held sincerity as he spoke, trying to bridge the gap created by the revelation."Emerie, you're my first real girlfriend. Paige was a mistake, and I regret it. With you, it's different. I've never felt this way before."

Emerie's conflicted emotions played on her face, caught between disappointment and the desire to believe Cole's words. The night air whispered around them as they navigated the complex terrain of trust and forgiveness.

Emerie was hesitant but wanting to believe."I need time to process this, Cole. It's a lot to take in."

——————-

Alex's words, laced with anger and frustration, cut through the night, reaching not only Cole but also Emerie, who stood at a distance, catching wind of the insinuations.

"Why don't you leave Emerie alone, huh? Why don't you go back to Erin or Paige or Olivia?" Alex's voice rang out, loud enough to make Emerie's heart skip a beat. The mention of Olivia, Erin, and Paige added fuel to the fire, each name a painful reminder of Cole's complicated history.

As the words reverberated through the air, Cole felt a surge of frustration and embarrassment. The accusations hit a nerve, even though the insinuations were far from the truth. He shot back, his tone defensive but laced with urgency, "You don't know anything, Alex. Just stay out of it."

Emerie, on the outskirts of the confrontation, felt a whirlwind of emotions. The revelation about Cole's past actions and the veiled insinuations left her feeling vulnerable and betrayed. She struggled to comprehend the complexity of the situation, caught between trust and doubt.

The insinuation about Olivia and Erin added another layer of complexity to an already tumultuous situation.

"Is that why you were hooking up with Olivia and Erin while you were supposedly trying to be with Emerie?" Alex's words cut through the tension, his eyes drilling into Cole as if seeking some explanation for the perceived betrayal.

Cole, caught off guard by the directness of the question, felt a surge of frustration. "No, it's not like that," he retorted, his voice strained. "Things are different now, and Emerie means everything to me."

Emerie, standing on the outskirts of the heated confrontation, felt a mix of emotions surge within her. The accusations and revelations were like a storm tearing through the serenity of her thoughts.

Tears welled up in her eyes, and her voice quivered as she finally spoke, her words carrying a blend of vulnerability and sorrow. "Cole, I trusted you. How could you keep all this from me? Wasn't honesty supposed to be the foundation of our relationship?"

The weight of the moment hung in the air, a heavy silence punctuated only by the distant crackling of the bonfire. The truth, now laid bare, created a rift that seemed to widen with each passing second.

Emerie, unable to bear the weight of the unfolding drama, took a step back, her gaze lingering on Cole for a moment. With a deep breath, she uttered the words that sealed the fate of their relationship. "We're done, Cole."

Without waiting for a response, she turned away, the flickering glow of the bonfire casting shadows on her tear-streaked face. Her fingers trembled as she dialed Sara's number, seeking solace in the comfort of a friend.