Creepypasta Oneshots

Cheater...(2) [Bloody painter x F!reader]

This was requested by many people so here it is! Hope you enjoy!
Gender: female
•••
3rd pov

My eyes slowly started to become bloodshot, my lip started trembling and the part under my eye began to get puffy, then one by one, tears began to fall.
“Cheater!” i yelled at my boyfriend, Helen.

***

Weeks have passed from that event, however [Name] still couldn't stop thinking about him and his betrayal.

Helen tried to talk to her a few times but she refused to just look at him.

Need of revenge filled her heart. She suffered, now it's their turn to do so.

Meanwhile in these past week a certain twitchy boy helped her through this.

To tell the truth, he hoped that the two would break up, selfish yes but he was deeply in love with her from the moment he met her.

After seeing what Helen did to her, he swore to protect her at all cost and maybe confess these burning feelings to her.

“Hey cp/n!” she waved at him.
“Hey [Name]! You seem happier than usual” he quirked a brow at her unusual behavior.

She nodded smiling.
“well that's good” he said ticking, glad she was feeling well.
She sat, more like threw herself, on the couch extremely close to where Toby was.

“I know how to make Helen feel jealous and regret it!” Toby’s face darkened but didn't show it.

“shoot the plan then” He asked now twitching slightly more. The fact that he was nervous didn't help his syndrome.

“Basically I'm gonna fake being in a relationship with someone but i don't know who and i was thinking...”

“i can help!” Toby immediately said. He didn't care whether it was fake or not, he would be with her and he also knew that Helen would be around her more often meaning they would have to pretend more.

“that’s what i was thinking! Toby you’re the best!” she exclaimed throwing her arms around his body.

Toby blushed underneath his mouthguard, he was embarrassed but didn't dare to move. It was all he wanted.

“Okay so, we begin being a couple from now on!” she said excited to see her cheater ex’s reaction.

And so they did.

Whenever Helen came around they would cuddle, kiss and hug.
Do whatever couples do.

It was a win-win situation for both of them; Toby got the chance to be her 'lover' and [Name] could make Helen jealous.

One day though, everything changed for both.

[Name] was relaxing in her room, listening to her favorite song while thinking of what to draw.

After the break up with Bloody Painter she wasn't sure if keep on drawing was a good idea but deep inside she was certain that a stupid ex couldn't inhibit her from what she always liked to do, even if it reminded her of him.

Her hands started moving automatically sketching a familiar face.
As she continued, that face soon began more and more recognizable.

Just as she was about to put her signature, Toby bursted in the room breathing like he was running for hours non-stop.

She immediately rushed to him.
“Toby, what happened? She asked watching as he twitched.

“[Name]! I-i hav-e to tel-l you someth-ing” he explained quickly.
Then continued.

“Helen is s-searching for my ass that's why I-I came he-re, sorry if I invaded yo-u or your privacy. But tha-t's also not the im-portant th-ing. I nee-d to tell y-ou that i don't wa-nt to pretend be-ing together anymor-e.”

Although he seemed nervous his face and voice told the opposite.
He was serious about this decision.

She felt tears starting to cloud her eyes but kept it inside. She began to wonder if she was the problem they all left her and started thinking about all the things she could change.

“I respect you decision Toby, may i tell you something before you go?”

He nodded. She felt her throat hurt from trying to keep the tears.

“I think i love you Toby.”

The tension in the room was present.

Toby was quiet and he was staring in an empty space.

He opened his mouth to speak but was interrupted by the door opening.

They both looked that way only to find bloody painter there.

“I knew it was fake! I knew it! [Name] you belong to me, i’m sorry for cheating, it wasn't my fault i wasn't in my right mind. Forgive me and get back with me.”

He implored.

“Toby doesn't like you [Name] but i do! I love you!”
He continued.

Toby was surprised by his fake words.
[Name] was disgusted by his words.

It's all fake, all fake, all fake, all fake.

“all fake” she repeated out loud making helen’s eyes widen in anger and surprise.

“What?”

“A cheater will always be one, i don't care if you weren't in your right mind you still did that. This bitch ain't yours anymore”

Toby was amused by this drama, mostly because Helen was getting exposed and roasted.

“now if you excuse me dear cheater i kindly ask you to get out of my room and go fuck someone else”

She said while shooing him out of her comfortable (f/c) room, sticking her middle finger in front of his face.

“now uh, were you about to say something?” she asked nervously chuckling.

“Y-yeah an-d i'l-l ev-en try no-t to t-tic tha-t mu-ch”

“I like you too [Name]”
He said biting his tounge to prevent any other sound to come out of him.
And eventually he succeed.

Well there she had her ‘happily ever after’

Or is it?