Random Book 2

Why All For One being Deku's father makes no sense and is bad writing.

WARNING: This chapter contains MANGA SPOILERS for My Hero Academia. If you're an anime only fan who doesn't want to know what happens in the manga or you're not caught up on the chapter I advise you click off right now. You have been warned.

Yo what's up guys it's Mario and Sonic fanboy and today we're going to be talking about one of (if not the) most controversial/confusing/overrated/overblown/terrible theories in My Hero Academia and that is All For One being Deku's father. Now on paper this does seem like a good theory because Horikoshi is a huge Star Wars fan but if you read/watch all of My Hero Academia you would know that this doesn't make any sense, due to lack of build-up, and based on recent chapters. And that's what we're going to be doing we're going to explain why All For One being Deku's dad makes no sense at all so without further a do let's get started.

Starting things off with lack of build up People try to make it seem like there was build up to this theory but honestly I seriously doubt that. I've read/watched My Hero Academia from start to the current day and I found no single build up that literally leads this theory to be true. Unless I missed something which I doubt I did. If I did please PLEASE tell me in the comments bellow because I'm CLEARLY missing something if that's the case, so anyways to give a perfect example of what proper build up looks like let's take a look at Dabi's reveal as Toya Todoroki which people try to use as an argument as to why Deku is in fact All For One's son, when in reality it's not the reason why Dabi being Toya made sense is because there was actual building like in appearance for example with Dabi having the same eyes as Shoto.

Or Dabi and Toya just so happens to have the same hairstyle and Endeavor stating that Toya had more fire power than his, especially considering blue fire is hotter than orange fire. More evidence of this build up is Todoroki and Dabi's seemingly first encounter when Shoto failed to save Bakugo at the forest camp where Dabi literally said Shoto's full name.

Or even better after Endeavor fought that High-End Dabi literally came up to Endeavor asking him if this is there first meeting in a way that appears to be not to be taken seriously.