LoveSick Ghostface x Reader

Chapter 19

He looks at me with a glare.

"And what if I am...?"

I didn't blink,

No.

I didn't move at all.

I couldn't even breathe either.

He's Billy.

Tommy's Billy.

"Answer me (Y/n)...what if I am Billy? What would you do?"

I opened my mouth but I couldn't say anything.

"I-I..."

"You'll what? Rat me out? Then what? I'll get arrested? It's not that easy...there's no evidence that I'm Billy...wanna know why?" He leans closer to me.

"W-Why?"

He smiled.

"Because I'm not Billy."

I stared at him in shock. He laughed, "(Y/n) there's no way that I'm Billy." I looked down at his chest again and touched it. From what I remembered, Billy's chest was more rough. Unlike Tommy's. "What's with you touching my chest? How would that prove I'm Billy?" I sighed.

Should I tell him? No, he'll 100% get mad and tell everyone I had a sexual encounter with Billy.

Then Billy would find out and possibly kill one of them...

But then again I'm breaking Billy's rule. He didn't want me talking to any of my friends. No matter what I do, I will always make him upset.

"I...I don't know..." I thought for a moment.

"If...If it really is Lui...how can I prove it...? There's two of them...who would be the second one?"

"There's two?"

I nod my head.

"Matty?"

I looked at him annoyed. "You really think Matty would do something like this?" He shrugged. "Hey, these things always come out to a big shock when the reveal happens."

"But you did open my mind a bit..."

"What do you mean?"

I closed my eyes. "I remembered Damien showing me an app where he can change his voice to Billy's...so there's a possibility that Billy might be a girl." I groaned remembering the bathing incident.

Billy is definitely a guy.

"Well...I know one of them is a guy...so...what if..the other one is...a girl?"

He smiled.

"Lui and Matty."

I groaned, rolling my eyes. "I just don't think it's Matty."

He hums. "Lui and Daisy? Lui and Suzie? Lui and Lily?" Tommy shrugs. "Hey maybe it could be Evan and Lily, those two weirdos love horror movies. Especially Evan."

Looking up at Tommy I see him closing his eyes. He still had his hands on my waist as we talked. "Evan and Lily? But both of them were there when I was on call with Billy." Tommy sighs. "Aaron can still be a suspect...there's two killers...sooo...Lui and Aaron? I don't know (Y/n) my brain is starting to hurt..." I groaned, pulling away from him. "We should get to class then...we've been out for a while..."

As I was about to leave. He stops me, "Is it true...? You're dating Billy...?" I looked down. "Yes..."

"Was it by choice?"

I stayed quiet. If I tell him...then..

"Yes...I was the one that made him date me..." He lets me go with a frown and I open the closet door to get out.