Can You Survive? ~ Until Dawn

Chapter 7 ~ Never have I ever

Josh's Pov

Once I got back to the lodge, I said hello to everyone and got started making a fire after truth or dare, (if you made the stay with the others choice) all while teasing Chris about Ashley and watching (y/n) out of the corner of my eye.

Something was wrong, I could feel it. I mean I knew she was struggling but she had told me everything, I think. I wouldn't blame her if she didn't tell me something I mean who would want to talk to me, I'm crazy.

I glanced at (y/n), who was giving Matt a stern look. Matt made eye contact with me, but looked away quickly. What were they hiding.

"Hey Matt can I talk to you real quick?" I asked.

"Yeah man, what's up?" Matt asked, walking over to where I was standing by the fireplace.

"Is there something going on between you and (y/n)?" I glared suspiciously.

"What? No! Why would you think that?" I looked into Matts eyes, searching for any signs of him lying, which I didn't find any.

"I-im sorry it's just you guys have been looking at each other all night a-and I guess I got jealous. Anyways is she okay?" I asked with genuine concern.

"Y-yeah she's fine." Matt obviously lied. He was a terrible liar, everytime he lied he would stutter and avoid eye contact.

"Matt tell me what's wrong with her." I begged. "Besides the obvious." I stated sadly, stealing a glance at (y/n) who was looking at me and Matt with a scared expression.

"I wasn't even supposed to know! It was an accident, but she made me promise not to tell anyone. I'm sorry."

Before I could continue questioning him, Mike spoke up and suggested we play never have I ever. Jessica held up various bottles of alcohol and I immediately agreed.

(Y/n) looked uneasy and I walked over to her, giving her my best smile. She gave me a halfharted smile and patted the seat next to her on the couch.

"Hey Joshua." She teased.

I cringed and laughed at her. "Hey (n/n), there's something I wanted to ask you."

"Shoot."

I thought for a second, trying to think of a good way to talk to her about this but for some reason I couldn't find the words. I was confused because we could usually talk about this stuff no problem, I would comfort her and she would comfort me. But something about this was different, something felt off.

I dismissed the question and sat down on the floor with my friends, getting really to play the drinking game.

(Y/n) didn't really want to play but we convinced her.

Me, (y/n), Sam, Ashley, Jessica, Mike, Matt, Emily and Chris all sat with a shot glass in from of us. We passed around bottles of Skyy vodka and Jeremiah Cragg. Once everyone had a shot of something, we began the game. Jessica had volunteered to go first and was thinking over her question.

"Oh I've got it!" Jessica exclaimed, smirking. "Never have I ever... kissed a member of the same sex."

(Y/n) blushed and I shot her an amused glance.

(Y/n), Ashley and Chris all took a shot quickly and looked away. I groaned internally and took a shot as well.

"What?" (Y/n) asked, laughing.

"It was from that stupid prank you guys pulled on me in truth or dare last year! When you blindfolded me and made Chris kiss me." I laughed, recalling the memory.