What's up guys it's me Phoenix and today we're going to be doing another debunk and this is actually the first debunk I am doing because I do plan on redoing my debunks like Hulk VS Doomsday, Android 18 VS Captain Marvel, Mega Man VS Astro Boy, Mewtwo VS Shadow, etc. Now before we start let me say that this Death Battle wasn't really too bad but it does have its flaws even though the fight itself looked amazing and I like how they did with Luigi and Tails in that fight, however the research of the fight is something that I have a problem with I didn't like how Luigi was presented in the battle and I do disagree with the outcome and before people say "Wow you're just doing this because you're a Mario fanboy." Now I actually think it's fine that they think Tails wins but the reasons as to why they say he wins is completely wrong and that's what I'll be going into detail as to why. But anyways without further a do let's get into this debunk.
Okay so the first issue I have for one of the reasons why Tails wins is that While Luigi technically has more combat experience, and has survived being Nintendo's whipping boy, Tails' skills and arsenal was more than the green capped plumber can handle. I agree Tails has a better arsenal but he does not have better skills, if I recall currently you said that Tails lacks hand-to-hand combat skills, without his gadgets the only moves he has is flying, Tail Swipe Attack, Rapid Tails Attack, Thunder Shoot Punt, and Spin Dash, that's pretty much it he doesn't have ALL of Sonic's abilities, meanwhile Luigi is just as skilled has Mario and has proven that he is time and time again.
The next problem I have with this fight is that His training with Sonic makes him faster and his superior mobility gave him complete control over the battlefield. True Tails is faster because he can keep up with Sonic at light speeds and can maneuver around the battle, however Luigi scales to Mario who's piloted the star diver and dodged meteors and if we say that Tails is faster than light the same standards apply to Luigi who is launched across galaxies in seconds. So Luigi can react to Tails's attacks. Plus I don't remember Tails every getting any training from Sonic in the games so I don't know where they got that from.
The next point is that I have the most problem with is that Tails is stronger too. He can move 10 tons, while Luigi struggles to lift a large radish. Not even close, first of all Luigi lifting a radish is non canon it was in Super Mario Bros 2 which is non canon because the entire game was all just a dream it never happened. Secondly Tails actually struggled to drag the 10 ton weight and he was using one of his rings to do it plus Luigi has lifted a castle and kicked it in the air the castle weighed 61,372,830 tons that is MUCH stronger than that 10 ton weight Tails dragged and unlike Tails, Luigi lifted the castle with no difficulty whatsoever. Based on the distance it was kicked Luigi must have exerted a force of around 3.47 megatons of TNT now I can already see you all typing in the comments that Luigi doing it is non canon but once again he scales to Mario who actually did do it in canon. Also I've stated this multiple times that lifting strength doesn't matter in a fight striking strength does Luigi is comparable to Mario who fought Donkey Kong who punched the moon out of the sky with a force 3,346 megatons of TNT making his striking strength planet level and if Mario's anywhere near as strong as Donkey Kong (and he should be because he fought on equal footing with him) than he was landing hits that were close to Planet level strength and since Luigi can scale to that this means that he gets the edge in strength as Tails has never shown anywhere close to that type of strength making Luigi massively stronger.
And the last point I have in this battle is that Tails' gadgets more than make up for any of his weaknesses. Not really because if I learn anything from what Bleach-Grimmjow told me about Batman VS Captain America is that gadgets are limited and don't last long and thanks to Luigi's strength, reaction speed, and toughness he can last long enough for Tails to eventually run out of gadgets, now Luigi will eventually run out of power ups and arsenal as well which leads down to no power ups or gadgets just skill vs skill in hand to hand combat, like I said earlier without any gadgets, Tails is pretty much a goner, sure he has his speed and can move around the battlefield by flying but Luigi can react to Tails's speed in combat speed and he can't fly forever he'll eventually get tired and land on the ground I mean Luigi has better hand to hand combat skills while Tails can hardly fight, thus giving Luigi the edge.
So in conclusion Luigi surpasses Tails in just enough edges in the category to prove himself to be the deadliest player 2 So in my opinion Luigi should've won this battle, now I'm not saying Luigi stomps Tails because it's a really close match but I see Luigi taking the majority, so unless if Tails has his Tornado than he should win this. Plus I think he'll need prep time in order to beat Luigi even though without prep he can think his way out of anything but Brains don't always beat Brons for example: Batman VS Captain America, Batman may be smarter but that doesn't matter when your opponent has many ways to disarm you of your weapons and beat you in hand to hand combat. Overall Tails may have the speed, intelligence, and arsenal advantage, however Luigi had the strength, durability, experience, and skills needed to claim his victory. And no for those of you who are thinking what I think you're thinking no I do not wanna see a rematch of this battle I know there's a lot Mario fanboys who wanna see a rematch of the fight because Mario VS Sonic got one and Mario won that but I highly doubt it will happen and even if they did I'm pretty sure they'll mess up there like they did here. But that's all for now thank you all so much for reading let me know what your think. Do you agree me that Luigi should've won or do you agree that Tails would win? Anyways that's all for now and I will see you all later. Peace out.

YOU ARE READING
Random Book
RandomSince everyone else is doing random books I might as well do the same thing.