Why? (A TommyInnit x Reader Fanfic)

Chapter 9

Wil shook his head. "Tommy, you're an idiot. You're like the last to know. The only one that doesn't know that you like Y/N is now Y/N."
I looked at him. "What?"
"They like you, Tommy," he said. "They really do. And it really hurt them to see you with someone else. I'm not going to tell you what to do, that's up to you. Amy and Y/N are both great people and whoever you choose is up to you."
I looked down at my phone. I got a text from Amy.

Amy: hey
Tommy: hey

"Amy texted me. What should I tell her?" I asked Wil.
"Whatever you want, Tommy. I'm not going to tell you what to do."

Amy: what's going on between you and Y/N?
Tommy: me and Y/N? We're just friends
Amy: really? I've seen the way you look at each other. It's obvious you like them
Tommy: oh
Amy: yeah. If you want to be with them it's fine with me
Tommy: really?
Amy: yeah really! Besides I don't think I'm really into guys that much
Tommy: really? Okay, we can still be friends, I'll support you no matter what
Amy: thanks tommy, glad we can still be friends!
Tommy: yeah, I'll talk to you later
Amy: okay

I smiled at my phone. "I've made my choice, Big Man."
"Really? Who's it gonna be?"
"Y/N," I said. "Amy even noticed that I like them and she's fine with it."
"That's great! You should probably get back to your movie."
"Yeah, alright, talk to you later, Big Man!"

I walked back out to the living room to see Y/N still cuddled up to Tubbo but now they're asleep.
Tubbo noticed I came back. "Shh!" He said, gesturing to Y/N.
I smiled and sat down. The movie was at the part where they met Doug.

"I'm gonna put them in their room," I whispered to Tubbo.
He nodded and moved them off of him, trying not to wake them. They woke up anyway, looking confused.
"Come on, Y/N, let's get you to bed," I said.
They nodded and slowly stood up.

I took them to their room and laid them on their bed.
"Tommy, why?" They said as I was leaving.
"Why what?" I asked, stopping in the doorway.
"Why can't you like me back? Why? Am I not good enough?"

I went back over to Y/N. I sat at the foot of their bed. They moved to lay on my shoulder. I wrapped my arm around them.

"Y/N."
"Hmm?"
"What makes you think I don't like you? What makes you think you're not good enough? To me, you're perfect. Don't ever think that you're not good enough."
"But what about Amy?"
"We broke up, she realized she likes girls more, and I realized I like you more."

Y/N looked up at me. "I really like you, Tommy."
"I really like you too, Y/N."

500 words!