5SOS Preferences

Pref 39 - Best Friend's Brother (Pt. 2)

Michael~

"You know he really means it when he says that you can trust him, right?"

"Yeah, I'm just scared that his intentions will change once I trust him, y'know?"

"Not really, but let's say I do... I know my brother so well! He really likes you."

"Really?" You ask, tinting pink. You couldn't help it, you haven't talked to a guy since your dad, so this is all new to you.

"Yes really."

"Dinner's ready!" you hear your best friend's mom call from the kitchen.

"Come on." She says to you, leaving her room for you to follow, so you do.

You come into the room to see the table all set and spaghetti and meatballs set at 5 of the 6 chairs.

"Thank you." I say, sitting down at the guest chair and waiting for everyone to sit down.

"I will say the prayer." Michael says, bowing his head. All of you guys join hands and he quickly says the prayer.

"Amen." Everyone mutters, before digging into the delicious meal. You take a bite and it is so good.

"This is so good." You compliment. Everyone nods in agreement.

"Thank you dear. It's my own recipe for the sauce."

You nod contently.

"(Y/N), I have a question." Michael says, taking a drink of his water.

"What is it?" You ask politely.

"I like this girl, and I need advice, because I mean, my sister knows nothing." He says, softly chuckling, which nearly sends your nerves over the edge.

"Hey!" She exclaims, throwing a napkin at him. Their parents just laugh, continuing their meal.

"Just ask her. Don't get nervous. She's human, and you're human."

"Okay, (Y/N) would you like to go on a date with me sometime?"

Calum~

"Did my sister tell you?" Calum asks, looking dorky and cute as always.

"Tell me what?" You ask, acting clueless.

"Well, I really like you."

"Awe, that's sweet."

"Would you like me to take you on a date sometime, I mean... Don't feel like you have to say yes. I'm just your best friend's brother, I probably mean nothing to you, like at all. I'm younger, and shorter, and terrible. You probably will never ever like me. Why did I even do this? You probably think I'm absolutely incredibly stupid and idiotic. You know what? You probably pity me. You probably feel bad for me, but even then I don't really expect you to say yes. I mean, I'm just me. You are like a model, and I-"

You cut him off by connecting your lips to his. The way that small connection makes you feel causes something heated, but before you deepen it, you stop the kiss. No need for any extra attention.

"I would love to go on a date with you Calum. And I don't pity you, because I like you too." You admit, blushing a bit. You look up to see your best friend giving you a thumbs up.

"So would you like to dance?" He asks you, so you let him pull you onto the dance floor.

Ashton~

"Look who I found." Ashton says, smirking after running into you. You nearly fell down and you just scoff, trying to get to the kitchen without anymore unwanted meet ups.

He grabs gently onto your arm, and you slightly wince. You don't show much emotion though, or at least you try not to let him notice.

"Did that hurt?" He asks, and you try to escape, but he now has a grip on your waist, while pulling up your sleeves to show scars etched. None of them were fresh you had stopped. A whole year clean.

"I can tell those aren't fresh. You stopped. That's good." He says, smiling. It looks like he actually cares, but he's probably acting.

"Yeah, yeah. Feel free to tease me, it's okay..." You say, still not being able to leave.

He looks you straight in the eyes.

"I do actually care. I know I am a senior and you are a junior, but I really do care. I've always cared, from afar. My sister would kill me if I hurt you, like at all."

"Oh." Is all you could mutter out in shock.

"Can I try something?" He asks. You nod, only because you couldn't vocalize right now.

He kisses you, passionately and slow. It felt amazing and your nerves were tingling. He pulls away too soon, making you want more of his touch.

"Will you go on a date with me?" He asks. You still couldn't vocalize, so you just jumped into his arms and nodded your head before hiding your face in his neck.

"You're so fucking adorable." He admits, lifting you off the floor and carrying you over his shoulder.

Luke~

"I still can't believe this is going to happen." You say to yourself, nothing could calm you right now.

Just then the door rings. You open the door to see Luke.

"Hello, ma'am." He says, bowing. You giggle and so does he.

"Hi." You say, trying not to be too awkward.

"Hey. You look amazing." He says, and you smile.

"I can't believe this is happening." You mutter under your breath.

"Yeah, going out with the Luke Hemmings is amazing."

Oh no, he heard you be smooth...

"No, I meant I can't believe I am wearing a dress. Your sister is amazingly manipulative."

"Oh." He says, looking sad.

"But going on a date with you is amazing."

"She told me that you had a crush on me."

"Damn, she told you?"

"Watch your language, babe." He says, smirking.

You slightly hit is shoulder, walking out the door.

"At least let me open the door for you. I'm trying to be a gentleman."

"Nope." He say, opening the door, getting in, and closing it on your own.

By the time he gets in the passenger seat, you are seat belted in and all ready for take off.

"I'm a big girl Luke, I'll be fine."

He slightly chuckles, before putting his car in drive. Off we go to a double date with his sister and her boyfriend. This will be interesting...

Hey guys! Hope you didn't mind the wait. Thanks for 29.7k!!! xx