Proxy in Command (Creepypasta X Reader)

Chapter 33

I slowly went upstairs on the mansion's porch. Again, I was outside at night without knowing the reason why. Before I twisted the doorknob, I felt this dark sensation. Something was wrong. I slowly opened the door before I opened my mouth in shock at the scene in front of me.

The pastas along with Slenderman were hung from the ceiling. They were all covered in blood and sweat. I covered my mouth with my hand as I felt my tears come out.

How did this happen?

"Welcome home, love," I heard Zalgo announce as he was on top of the stairway.

"What did you do!" I screamed at the top of my lungs.

"I gave you a choice, but you didn't take it. Now you must deal with the consequences."

"What choice are you talking about! I don't remember!" I cried as I kept staring at their corpses.

"You'll see, my dove."

My eyes shot open as I looked at my surroundings. Sally was asleep next to me. I had probably fallen into a deep slumber seeing as I didn't feel her get in.

I wiped off my tears before finally getting up to get ready. Once it was nine, I gently shook Sally awake.

She mumbled a few words before her eyes opened to reveal her green eyes. I smiled as she let out a yawn.

"I want pancakes," she randomly said as she raised her hands in the air. I chucked as I lifted her. She laid her head on my shoulder and wrapped her legs around my waist.

"What time did you arrive?" I asked her as I opened the door.

"Around ten-thirty. Slendy came and told us the party ended. I woke up a few hours ago because I had a nightmare so I went to your room."

I held her tighter and made sure to watch my step as I went down the stairs.

"Do you want to talk about your nightmare?" I asked her.

"I dreamt that you joined Zalgo's side and left me alone here. You turned evil and tried to attack us with Zalgo."

I stopped my tracks as I looked at her. She had her eyes closed as she faced me.

"Did you see him?"

She opened her eyes and nodded. "He looked scary."

I couldn't help but think Zalgo was the one behind this. If that was the case, he just messed with the wrong person.

"Don't worry Sal, I will never leave you," I reassured her as I finished going downstairs.

"You promise?" She asked.

"I promise."

We then made our way to the dining room only to see Splendor, Trender, E.J, Painter, and the proxies. I gently lifted Sally down so that we could both sit in our seats.

The door was then slammed by Jeff who held his head with his hand.

"Why was I sleeping in the living room?"

Oh right, I had knocked him out.

"Do you remember anything from last night?" I asked.

He shook his head as he hissed. "Damn it Y/N, speak softer. I have a headache."

Masky threw him a bottle of pills which Jeff easily caught.

"Take two, it should help."

Jeff nodded as he sat in his seat.