Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios (Male Reader)

Candy Pop - Part One

FIRST ENCOUNTER -

You gasped and sat up suddenly, looking around, faintly hearing a male's voice but saw your brother and tried to calm down.

"You good? Have your breath?"

You gulped and covered your face, shaking your head. "I feel like they get worse." You said with a scoff.

(B/N) hummed. "What was it about?"

"I don't know but I hate how terrified I am right now." You said before shaking your head. "I'm gonna get something to drink."

"Don't you hate when that happens? Not remembering anything about it."

You went into the kitchen, grabbing a water bottle. "Why are you even up?" You questioned as you opened it.

(B/N) snorted. "Being an awesome brother, I decided to stay up."

With a look of disbelief, your brother shrugged. "You were whimpering and stuff so I stayed up."

Inviting your brother to keep an eye on you seemed like a good idea. Nightmares and night terrors were making you avoid any sleep. For some reason, having your brother just felt better.

You nodded, drinking some water and closing the bottle, sitting on the couch. He groaned as he lost the level before standing up. "Since you're up, I'll take a break and get some food. Want something?" He asked, grabbing his coat and keys.

"Not really."

"Then I'll be back." With that, your brother left, leaving you to switch to TV and watch a movie.

As you started to doze off, you heard small jiggling noises. Sluggishly sitting up, you looked around and yawned. "(B/N)?"

When you didn't get a response, you shrugged and laid down but stopped at the feeling of something grabbing your shirt. Shrugging it off, you felt it at your feet. Then your arms.

It was everywhere!

Eyes open in panic as you struggled before hearing a voice. "Hm, you seem different."

You squirmed, whimpering and trying to pry off the hands but it wasn't working. Then you saw him, it, whatever it was.

The jester creature stood in front of you and your heart drop as you took in their appearance. Blue hair, black lines under his eyes, purple dots on his cheeks, the jester outfit, and a huge mallet in one hand.

You cried out when he grabbed your chin, moving your face side to side, opened your mouth, tugged your hair.

"Because you aren't the one I'm looking for." He uttered and before you knew it, you were back with just your blanket on your lap and you looked up, completely terrified.

"I apologize, boy."

You stared at him and flinched when he held a hand to you. "Night Terrors." Then shrugged. "Or Candy Pop."

"We aren't meeting again!" You managed to shout before you heard your front door and turned to see your brother. You looked in front of you and saw 'Night Terrors' was gone.

Then you heard a confused hum. "Hey, you okay?"

You turned to your brother and shook your head. "I don't know."

MEETING AGAIN -

Nightmares were gone. It literally seems like that Night Terrors or whoever got the wrong person. Like a wrong phone number.

Your brother left with a fuss. Going on and on about how he could stay longer if you wanted. Eventually, you were able to get him to leave. When he did, you debating when to go to bed.