Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios (Male Reader)

M/R got Horns/Wings

Offenderman-

"You know..."

"Don't say it.." You muttered into the pillow that you were hugging. "Not a word."

Offender looked at the small but noticeable horns on your head. "Hey, hey, don't get shy on me. Tell me what happened." He said with a small chuckle.

You scoffed and lifted your head. "I went to bed then woke up to something ripping and saw my pillow was ripped and I had horns on my head."

He nodded before shrugging. "Yeah, I don't know but hey, you still look cute."

With a small snort, you laid back and covered your face with your arms. "Why does this keep happening to me!" You whined loudly. Offender chuckled and laid next to you. "You know, you don't look so bad with them."

You turned to look at him and sighed. "Well, I guess I'm glad you like it."

"Yeah, I want to take a picture. I'm gonna keep count of how many weird things happen to you." He said, smiling widely. "First the dog ears, then the clone, and now, this."

With a small scoff, you hit him with your pillow and turned away. "You suck." You muttered while he laughed and turned his body to you. "I love you." He whispered, making you hum. Then you felt his hand on your head, tapping the horns.

"This is kinda funny."

"Leave me alone."

Hoodie-

He walked through that door and was confused by the feathers on the ground. "A new bird?" He whispered but the feathers were a bit big to be a pet bird.

"Hey, babe, why are there feathers on the ground?" He asked loudly, bending down and picking up a red feather. Then he heard you shout something from your room after a faint crash and he walked to it. "What was that?"

"Don't come in!" You shouted, slamming the door shut.

Hoodie didn't even reach the door before chuckling sheepishly. "M/R?" He asked, leaving you to cover your face and sigh loudly. "I have wings!"

He stared at your bedroom door before laughing. "Come on, M/R, that's your excuse?"

Then the door swung open and he went quiet, seeing what you just told him.

You tapped your foot before smiling nervously. "I am a little scared. I have wings."

Hoodie blinked before walking behind you and looked at the wings and covered his mouth with a mumble of some words. "Wings?" He questioned, making you nod and turn to him but he gasped when he got slapped by one of your new wings. "M/R!"

You gasped and grabbed his face. "Are you okay? I've trying to get use to them but it's hard."

He nodded and scoffed. "Okay, so, they just popped up?"

"Literally." You answered.

"Literally?" He questioned.

"Yeah, I was making some food then." You made a ripping noise. "Poof, red wings."

Hoodie just stared at you. "Oh, boy..."

Laughing Jack-

Lj was holding his chin while you sat on the bed, wings attached you. "So, they just...are there?" He asked, tilting his head a little, making you nod. "I woke up to it and didn't know what to do. So, I just stayed home and did my best to just go on with my day."

"How successful have you been?"

You seemed to think about it before nodding a little. "It hasn't been too hard." He nodded before looking at them. "It's like you turned to a real Batman." He said before chuckling to himself.